Skip to content
Episode 440 April 16, 2025 · 01:07:23
440. Red Corn Roundup with Roadies

440. Red Corn Roundup with Roadies

Jim & Todd taste four heirloom red corn whiskeys — Still Austin BIB, W.H. McBrayer Batch 3, High Wire Jimmy Red, and Wood Hat Bloody Butcher — with guests Doug Keller and Col. Jeremy Tilley.

The Bourbon Road Media Player

Reviews

Show Notes

Jim Shannon and Todd Ritter welcome two special guests to the Bourbon Road Bar for a deep dive into heirloom red corn whiskeys. Joining the hosts are Doug Keller, a returning roadie and artist known for his bourbon-inspired paintings, and his cousin Jeremy Tilley, a retired Air Force Colonel and self-described bourbon newcomer still finding his footing on the trail. The four gather around the tasting mat to explore how two distinct heirloom corn varieties — Jimmy Red and Bloody Butcher — express themselves across four very different craft bottles, alternating back and forth between the two varieties to draw out the subtle character differences each corn brings to the glass.

On the Tasting Mat:

  • Still Austin Red Corn Bottled in Bond: A 100-proof, four-year-old bottled-in-bond bourbon from Still Austin Distillery in Austin, Texas, crafted with a mash bill of 36% Jimmy Red corn, 34% white corn, 25% rye, and 5% barley. Master blender Nancy Fraley shapes this limited summer release into a pour that delivers a nutty, cedar-tinged nose with cigar-box qualities, followed by a lively palate offering bright fruit — strawberry and raspberry — alongside rich caramel and a gentle spice on the sides of the tongue. A sessionable, refined expression that punches above its modest proof. (00:05:35)
  • W.H. McBrayer Judge McBrayer Batch 3: A 103.5-proof craft bourbon from McBrayer Legacy Spirits, this expression is built on an 88.4% Bloody Butcher corn mash bill, with just 5.8% heritage rye and 5.8% malted barley — making it nearly a corn whiskey in composition. The recipe traces back to a historical note from Judge McBrayer to E.H. Taylor. The nose opens bright and surprisingly floral given the earthy corn base, while the palate delivers a distinct umami quality — an organic, mushroomy earthiness reminiscent of puff-ball fungi — alongside pop-rocks spice and a dry, slightly tannic finish. Complex and layered, with much going on in every sip. Retails around $99.99 and is available in limited quantities through the McBrayer Legacy Club or Slab Box. (00:15:23)
  • High Wire Distilling Jimmy Red Single Barrel: A single-barrel bourbon from High Wire Distilling in Charleston, South Carolina, bottled at cask strength 116 proof and aged a minimum of three and a half years on Jimmy Red corn. This Total Wine barrel pick pours notably darker than the Still Austin, suggesting significant wood extraction. The nose is rich and inviting, and the palate is remarkably viscous and mouth-coating — a wall-to-wall flavor experience with prominent caramel, hints of dark chocolate, and a full-bodied warmth that reaches every corner of the palate simultaneously. Retails around $99.99. (00:36:30)
  • Wood Hat Spirits Bloody Butcher Cast Strength Corn Whiskey: A cast-strength corn whiskey from Wood Hat Spirits, a small wood-fired distillery in Florence, Missouri, clocking in at 123.4 proof. The distillery uses a unique heat-transfer oil system fired by wood to cook the mash. The nose carries a sharp herbal edge with deep fig and earthy molasses notes, while the palate is intensely concentrated, chewy, and rich — a syrupy thickness that sits heavily on the back of the palate with pronounced barrel character suggesting smaller cooperage was likely used at some point. An after-dinner pour ideally suited to a cigar or a slice of carrot cake. Retails around $99.99. (01:00:23)

With four bottles all landing around the same $99–$100 price point, today's tasting is a pure flavor exercise — a rare chance to isolate how heirloom corn variety shapes whiskey character across distilleries, regions, and production philosophies. Whether you're a seasoned collector or, like Jeremy, still discovering what's in the glass, the red corn world offers a compelling and delicious detour off the beaten bourbon trail.

Full Transcript

Still Austin W.H. McBrayer High Wire Distilling Wood Hat Spirits Jimmy Red corn Bloody Butcher corn heirloom corn bourbon red corn whiskey craft bourbon single barrel bourbon bottled in bond cast strength Nancy Fraley McBrayer Legacy Spirits Charleston South Carolina bourbon Florence Missouri whiskey corn whiskey bourbon tasting bourbon trail small batch bourbon

The Conversation