Skip to content
Episode 393 May 8, 2024 · 01:11:52
393. Rise of American Single Malts

393. Rise of American Single Malts

Rob, Todd & Amzie join Jim in the Rare Eagle Bar to explore 4 American Single Malts: Bulleit 10yr, Atelier V, Old Line Navy Strength, and Cedar Ridge Tokaji Finished.

The Bourbon Road Media Player

Reviews

Show Notes

Jim Shannon welcomes listeners back to another episode recorded inside Rob Carter's legendary Rare Eagle Bar in Shelbyville, Kentucky. Joining Jim and Rob for a Sunday afternoon session are two familiar faces from the Frankfurt Bourbon Society — Todd Ritter and Amzie Winnie. The four friends dig into a category that is gaining serious momentum in the American whiskey world: American Single Malt Whiskey. Each guest brought a bottle, and the group works through all four together, sharing tasting notes, backstories, and plenty of conversation about where this emerging category is headed.

On the Tasting Mat:

  • Bulleit 10 Year American Single Malt Whiskey: Bottled by Bulleit Distilling Co. in Shelbyville, Kentucky at 90 proof and aged 10 years in new American oak. Suspect provenance points toward MGP or a contract distillery partner. On the nose the group found honeycomb, floral notes reminiscent of lavender or heather, and a light, earthy spice — almost like a single drop of Amburana had been added. The palate is smooth and refreshing for its proof, with honey-tea sweetness, a whisper of citrus, and a gently drying finish. An approachable, warm-weather pour available at major retailers like Kroger for around $60. (00:03:27)
  • Atelier V American Single Malt Whiskey: Produced by Jed Haas at Atelier V Distillery in New Orleans, Louisiana — a one-man operation tucked inside an industrial artist colony — this 94-proof expression is aged a minimum of two years in used American oak barrels. The nose leans slightly toward classic Scotch character, with a faint medicinal or iodine note suggesting lightly smoked or peated malt, alongside stonefruits, fresh-baked bread, and a gentle floral quality. On the palate it is well-rounded for its youth, with complementary layers that do not let the finish overwhelm the base spirit. Amzie acquired it during a distillery visit with his wife and calls it a unique find worth seeking out on any trip to New Orleans. Approximately $60. (00:35:51)
  • Old Line Navy Strength American Single Malt Whiskey: Bottled in Baltimore, Maryland and distilled in Columbus, Ohio, this bold expression clocks in at 114 proof — the historical "Navy Strength" threshold once used to ensure spirits could survive long sea voyages. Aged in virgin American oak with no age statement, it pours notably darker than the first two bottles. The nose delivers stewed cherries, cooked fruit, and cocoa, with brown sugar richness. The palate follows through with cherry cobbler, a drizzle of chocolate, a touch of anise, and a lingering warmth. Todd first encountered it as a blind single-barrel pour from a friend and was immediately captivated. Retails around $55–$60. (00:39:30)
  • Cedar Ridge Quintessential Series Tokaji Finished American Single Malt Whiskey: Produced by Cedar Ridge Distillery in Swisher, Iowa under master distiller Murphy Quint, this 117.8-proof expression is finished in Hungarian Tokaji dessert wine casks — a wine made from grapes left to dry on the vine, historically known as the "King of Wines." The nose is extraordinary: bready and yeasty like fresh dough, layered with canned fruit medley, stewed pears, dried grape and raisin, and a jammy sweetness. The palate adds caramel drizzle over the fruit and a richness that recalls bread pudding or raisin pie. At 117.8 proof it drinks with surprising integration, the wine cask finish amplifying rather than masking the base malt spirit. Available for around $69. (00:52:29)

The group wraps up the session reflecting on how accessible and diverse the American Single Malt category has become — four bottles ranging from 90 to 117.8 proof, from Louisiana to Iowa to Maryland, all landing around $60. Whether you are new to whiskey or a seasoned bourbon veteran ready to explore, this episode makes a strong case that American Single Malt deserves a place on every whiskey lover's shelf. Raise a glass to the distillers pushing the envelope, and as always, we'll see you down the Bourbon Road.

Full Transcript

American single malt whiskey Bulleit 10 Year Cedar Ridge Distillery Atelier V Distillery Old Line Spirits Tokaji finish Navy strength whiskey Frankfurt Bourbon Society Todd Ritter Amzie Winnie Rob Carter Jim Shannon Rare Eagle Bar Murphy Quint Iowa whiskey New Orleans distillery Baltimore whiskey single malt tasting malted barley whiskey craft distillery

The Conversation