Skip to content
Episode 393 May 8, 2024 · 01:11:52
393. Rise of American Single Malts

393. Rise of American Single Malts

Jim, Rob, Todd & Amzie crack four American Single Malts — Bulleit 10yr, Atelier V, Old Line Navy Strength, and Cedar Ridge Tokaji Finished — live in the Rare Eagle Bar.

The Bourbon Road Media Player

Tasting Notes

Show Notes

Welcome back to the Bourbon Road! This week, host Jim Shannon gathers the crew inside the legendary Rare Eagle Bar — the personal home collection of co-host Rob Carter — for a deep dive into the world of American Single Malt whiskey. Joining Jim and Rob are two familiar faces from the Frankfort Bourbon Society: Todd Ritter and Amzie Winnie. Each guest brought a bottle to share, and together the four work their way through a fascinating flight that spans geography, proof, age, and finish — from a 90-proof 10-year-old out of Kentucky to a Hungarian Tokaji-finished beast from Iowa cracking in at nearly 118 proof.

On the Tasting Mat:

  • Bulleit 10 Year American Single Malt Whiskey (90 proof): Bottled by Bulleit Distilling Co. of Shelbyville, KY, this 10-year-old single malt is believed to be sourced (possibly from MGP) and aged in new American oak. The pour lands at 90 proof with a light, refreshing character. Tasting notes include honeycomb, wildflower honey, citrus zest, floral lavender or heather, and a gently spiced finish with just a touch of dryness on the back. A warm-weather sipper with broad approachability and a retail price around $60. (00:03:27)
  • Atelier V American Single Malt Whiskey (94 proof): Distilled at Atelier V, a one-man artisan operation housed in a converted artist colony in New Orleans, LA. Aged at least two years in used American oak barrels and bottled at 94 proof. The nose suggests a lightly medicinal, faintly scotch-like character with stone fruits, fresh bread, and a delicate floral quality. On the palate, pear and plum notes emerge alongside a gentle herbal thread — approachable, well-rounded, and a genuine surprise from the Gulf Coast. Retail is approximately $60. (00:17:50)
  • Old Line Navy Strength American Single Malt Whiskey (114 proof): Bottled in Baltimore, MD and distilled in Ohio, this Navy Strength expression clocks in at a commanding 114 proof. Aged in virgin American oak with no age statement, it delivers a dramatically richer profile than the first two pours: cooked cherry, stewed fruit, cocoa, brown sugar, and a warmly spiced finish with anise and caramel. Dense and rewarding, with an almost dessert-like richness. Retail around $55–$60. (00:35:43)
  • Cedar Ridge Distillery Quintessential Series Tokaji Finished American Single Malt Whiskey (117.8 proof): From Cedar Ridge Distillery in Swisher, Iowa, master distiller Murphy Quint's flagship single malt receives a finish in Tokaji dessert wine casks — the legendary Hungarian "wine of kings." Bottled at 117.8 proof, the nose is a stunning convergence of fruit compote, canned fruit medley, fresh bread batter, and jammy stone fruit. The palate brings caramel drizzle, raisin, dried grape, and a long, warming finish with layers of preserved fruit and baking spice. Retail around $69. (00:52:29)

Beyond the bottles, the conversation roams widely and warmly: the crew discusses the growing American single malt category, the case for new oak versus used casks, the history of Navy Strength proof, the origins of gin and tonics as a quinine delivery system, and why the Frankfort Bourbon Society is a must-visit destination for any bourbon tourist rolling through central Kentucky. Whether you're a seasoned malt drinker or a bourbon lover looking for your next obsession, this episode is your invitation to explore one of whiskey's most exciting frontiers.

Full Transcript

American single malt whiskey Bulleit 10 year single malt Atelier V distillery New Orleans Old Line Navy Strength Cedar Ridge distillery Iowa Tokaji finished whiskey Frankfort Bourbon Society Rare Eagle Bar Jim Shannon Rob Carter Todd Ritter Amzie Winnie Murphy Quint single malt bourbon comparison Navy strength proof Hungarian Tokaji wine cask craft distillery whiskey American whiskey tasting single malt tasting notes bourbon podcast