Skip to content
Episode 426 January 8, 2025 · 01:04:38
426. Whiskey Review Kickoff 2025

426. Whiskey Review Kickoff 2025

Jim & Todd taste Brothers Bond Blended Rye, Wyoming National Parks #4, Casey Jones 10th Anniversary, and Angel's Envy 2024 Cask Strength.

The Bourbon Road Media Player

Reviews

Show Notes

Jim Shannon and Todd Ritter kick off 2025 with a spirited new-year tasting session, working their way through four diverse American whiskeys sent in by distillery partners. The guys open up about dry January, the shifting secondary market, and what the newly codified American Single Malt designation might mean for the industry — all while steadily climbing the proof ladder from an easy-sipping 95-proof rye up to a rich cask-strength port-finished bourbon.

On the Tasting Mat:

  • Brothers Bond American Blended Rye Whiskey: Distilled at MGP in Indiana from a four-grain mash of 77% rye, 16% corn, 7% wheat, and 7% barley, aged a minimum of four years in char 4 stave / char 2 head barrels, and bottled at 95 proof (~$47 MSRP). On the nose it opens with a fresh, cool mint character and a light floral lift. The palate is silky and well-balanced with subtle sweetness, a gentle oily texture, soft spice, caramel, brown sugar, and a hint of citrus on the finish. (00:06:46)
  • Wyoming Whiskey National Parks Small Batch #4 (Mammoth Hot Springs): A five-year Kentucky-style bourbon made from 68% corn, 20% rye, and 12% barley, bottled at 98 proof (~$74.99 MSRP). The nose offers light, airy notes of caramel apple, juicy fruit gum, and a candy-like sweetness. On the palate there is sweet cornbread character, toffee, a touch of graininess, and a butterscotch-edged finish with a slightly sharp, tannic tail. Part of an annual series that benefits the national parks. (00:16:03)
  • Casey Jones Founders 10th Anniversary Blend: A distillery specialty spirit blending 75% five-year barrel-cut whiskey (corn and cane sugar, aged in the distillery's signature square pot still) with 25% five-year straight bourbon mash bill #1, bottled at 103.6 proof (~$99.99 MSRP). The nose is buttery and inviting with cotton candy, marshmallow, and stewed-fruit compote aromas. The palate surprises with savory oak influence, root beer, amaretto-like almond, Christmas spice, and an earthy, warming finish. A genuinely unique and festive limited release from the Hopkinsville, Kentucky distillery. (00:29:44)
  • Angel's Envy 2024 Cask Strength Bourbon (Port Finish): This year's annual cask-strength release from the Louisville distillery blends barrels finished in both tawny and ruby port wine casks, clocking in at 118.8 proof (~$230 MSRP). The nose is more restrained than expected — baking spice, Luxardo cherry, and a hint of grape. On the palate it delivers a robust and savory profile: almond extract, leather, cherry cola, tobacco, and deep oak, with the tawny port lending earthy complexity rather than overt grape sweetness. Rich mahogany color completes the package. (00:45:22)

Jim and Todd close out the episode by reflecting on the state of the bourbon market heading into 2025 — from softening secondary prices and declining bottle flipping to the enduring strength of bourbon tourism on Louisville's Whiskey Row. Four distinct styles, four different price points, and a clear reminder that proof alone doesn't determine a winner. Cheers to a great new whiskey year.

Full Transcript

Brothers Bond Brothers Bond Rye Wyoming Whiskey National Parks Bourbon Casey Jones Distillery Angel's Envy Angel's Envy Cask Strength port finish bourbon blended rye whiskey MGP American single malt dry January bourbon secondary market bourbon tourism Hopkinsville Kentucky Louisville distillery cask strength bourbon small batch bourbon specialty spirit bourbon tasting

The Conversation