Skip to content
Episode 410 September 11, 2024 · 47:27
410. Bourbon Heritage Month Roundup

410. Bourbon Heritage Month Roundup

Jim & Todd taste James E. Pepper Decanter, Templeton Midnight Rye, Bardstown x Silver Oak, and Maker's Mark The Heart — four bottles, four different stories.

The Bourbon Road Media Player

Reviews

Show Notes

Jim Shannon and Todd Ritter are back in Studio B — the corner of a rickhouse in Frankfort, Kentucky, home of the Frankfort Bourbon Society — for another round of carefully chosen pours. This week the duo works through four bottles that span the spectrum from straightforward Kentucky bourbon to wine-blended rye whiskey and barrel-finished expressions, keeping prices reasonable and the conversation lively the whole way through.

On the Tasting Mat:

  • James E. Pepper Decanter Bourbon: A 105.8-proof, five-year-old straight bourbon produced from James E. Pepper's own distillate at their Lexington, Kentucky distillery. Bottled as part of their Decanter series — a nod to a mid-twentieth-century bottle shape — this wheater-adjacent, likely high-rye mash enters the barrel at low proof, yielding a notably soft texture. The nose shows a measured alcohol presence without singeing; the palate delivers fresh berry and raspberry brightness, buttered toast, and a caramel drizzle on the finish. Retails around $56.99. (00:02:12)
  • Templeton Midnight Rye: A 90-proof American rye whiskey blended with dark port wine, bottled by Templeton Rye out of Iowa. Labeled transparently as a rye-and-port blend rather than a finished whiskey, this 750 ml expression retails for $39.99. The nose is jammy and deeply fruited — blackberry cobbler with a bready, buttery quality. The palate follows through with dark berry preserve on buttered toast, making for an unambiguous dessert-style sipper. A lower-proof, easy-entry pour well suited to cocktail experimentation or introducing new tasters to pulled tasting notes. (00:11:05)
  • Bardstown Bourbon Company x Silver Oak Collaboration Series: A 108-proof Kentucky straight bourbon finished for 17 months in Silver Oak California Cabernet Sauvignon American oak barrels. The blend draws from nine-to-fourteen-year-old source bourbons, and arrives in Bardstown's signature miniature sample bottle. The nose is fresh and lightly fruited with a dusty rickhouse character and a subtle nuttiness. On the palate, fresh orchard and wine fruit play alongside nutty, barrel-driven notes, with a mineral quality on the finish and a long, persistent mid-palate presence. Retails in the $149–$159 range. (00:23:05)
  • Maker's Mark "The Heart" Wood Finishing Series (First Release): The seventh installment of Maker's Mark's annual Wood Finishing Series, this expression uses the standard 70% corn, 16% wheat, 14% malted barley mash bill and clocks in at 111.7 proof. Designated BR22A, the release focuses on a specific stave treatment developed in partnership with Independent Stave Company. The nose is soft and approachable for the proof, showing light cherry and a hint of maple syrup. The palate opens gently before building into baking spice and caramel with maple persistence, a touch of dark chocolate on the back, and a medium finish. Retails for $68.99. (00:34:50)

Jim and Todd close the session with high marks across the board at accessible price points — and a running joke about peanut butter whiskey and port wine that may or may not inspire a future cocktail. Bourbon on the Banks in Frankfort, Kentucky on October 5th is on the horizon, and the guys tease an announcement about who will be pouring at the Bourbon Road bar. Subscribe, find the show on all major platforms, and join the Bourbon Roadies private Facebook group to keep the conversation going until next week.

Full Transcript

James E. Pepper Templeton Rye Bardstown Bourbon Company Maker's Mark Silver Oak port wine whiskey finished bourbon wood finishing series Kentucky bourbon rye whiskey collaboration series Lexington distillery Frankfort Kentucky bourbon tasting barrel finishing Cabernet Sauvignon barrel The Heart release Decanter bourbon Bourbon on the Banks bourbon podcast

The Conversation