Skip to content
Episode 410 September 11, 2024 · 47:27
410. Bourbon Heritage Month Roundup

410. Bourbon Heritage Month Roundup

Jim & Todd taste James E. Pepper Decanter, Templeton Midnight Rye, Bardstown BBC x Silver Oak, and Maker's Mark The Heart on this week's tasting mat.

The Bourbon Road Media Player

Tasting Notes

Show Notes

Jim Shannon and Todd Ritter are back in Studio B — the corner of a rick house in Frankfort, Kentucky, home of the Frankfort Bourbon Society — for a four-bottle tasting that leans heavily into finished and blended whiskeys. Three of the four pours feature some kind of extra-maturation or wine blending, and the lineup spans a wide price range from $39.99 all the way up to $159, giving roadies plenty to consider for every occasion and budget.

On the Tasting Mat:

  • James E. Pepper Decanter Bourbon: A 105.8-proof, five-plus-year straight bourbon made entirely from James E. Pepper's own distillate at their Lexington, Kentucky distillery. Bottled in a wide, flat decanter inspired by a mid-century original, this wheated-adjacent release shows bright berry and raspberry fruit, buttered toast, a drizzle of caramel, and a soft, silky texture attributed to low barrel-entry proof. Retails around $56.99. (00:02:12)
  • Templeton Midnight Rye: A 90-proof American rye whiskey blended with dark port wine, produced in Iowa at $39.99. The nose opens with jammy blackberry and warm bread, leading to a palate that Jim and Todd land squarely on blackberry cobbler — buttery, bready, and unambiguously dessert-forward. A conversation-starter for whiskey newcomers and cocktail experimenters alike. (00:11:05)
  • Bardstown Bourbon Company Collaboration Series – Silver Oak: A 108-proof Kentucky straight bourbon finished for 17 months in Silver Oak Cabernet Sauvignon American oak barrels, blended from nine-to-fourteen-year-old stocks. The nose is fresh and lightly nutty with a dusty rick-house quality; the palate offers bright fresh fruit, walnut, and a mineral finish. Available via Seelbach's and select retailers for approximately $149–$159. (00:22:09)
  • Maker's Mark Wood Finishing Series – The Heart (BR22A, First Release): The seventh installment of Maker's Mark's annual wood-finishing series, bottled at 111.7 proof from their 70/16/14 corn-wheat-malted barley mash bill. Soft and approachable on the nose despite its proof, with light cherry and a hint of maple; the palate layers baking spice, caramel, maple, and a whisper of chocolate before a medium finish. Retails at $68.99 with wide national distribution. (00:33:39)

Jim and Todd close out the episode with plans for Bourbon on the Banks (October 5th, Frankfort, KY) and a teaser about who might be pouring at the Bourbon Road tent. Todd is also about to fly to Savannah for a work conference — and yes, he already has a restaurant list. Cheers, roadies, and we'll see you down the Bourbon Road.

Full Transcript

Tasting Bourbon Rye Wheated Kentucky Bardstown Bourbon Company James E Pepper Pepper Decanter Bourbon Lexington Kentucky distillery Templeton Rye Midnight Rye port wine whiskey Bardstown Bourbon Company Silver Oak collaboration Cabernet Sauvignon finish Maker's Mark Wood Finishing Series The Heart bourbon BR22A bourbon tasting finished whiskey blended whiskey Frankfort Kentucky Bourbon on the Banks wheated bourbon rye whiskey bourbon review