Skip to content
Episode 421 December 4, 2024 · 51:55
421. Lost Lantern Whiskey

421. Lost Lantern Whiskey

Adam Polanski of Lost Lantern Whiskey joins Todd to pour through four stunning 10-year single casks: Thomas Foolery Ohio Bourbon, Spirit Works California Rye, NY Distilling Co. Rye & Westland Peated Single Malt.

The Bourbon Road Media Player

Tasting Notes

Show Notes

Todd Ritter holds down the fort solo while Jim Shannon soaks up the Florida sun, welcoming Adam Polanski — co-founder and head of whiskey sourcing for Lost Lantern Whiskey — to the show. Lost Lantern is an independent bottler modeled on the Scottish independent bottling tradition, sourcing single casks and small batches from craft distilleries across the United States and releasing them with full transparency about their origin. Adam and Todd pour through the brand's Fall 2024 Single Cask Collection, a milestone lineup of four expressions all aged ten years (or very nearly so) from distilleries in Ohio, California, New York, and Washington State — a testament to how far the American craft whiskey movement has matured.

On the Tasting Mat:

  • Lost Lantern Thomas Foolery 10 Year Old Ohio Straight Bourbon: Single cask, cask strength release at 59.7% ABV (119.4 proof) from Thomas Foolery Distillery near Lake Erie in Ohio. Mash bill of 63% corn, 10% rye, and 27% malted barley. The cooler, snow-belt climate near Lake Erie yields a bourbon with impressive depth, delivering rich maple, green apple, dark fruit, and dark chocolate with a notably smooth, velvety mouthfeel. (00:03:54)
  • Lost Lantern Spirit Works 10 Year Old California Straight Rye: Single cask, cask strength at 69.6% ABV (139.2 proof) from Spirit Works Distillery in Sebastopol, California. Mash bill of 70% rye, 10% malted rye, and 20% malted barley. The maritime Sonoma wine-country climate shapes a bright, floral, and fruit-forward rye with lemon meringue on the nose and a palate of citrus, spearmint, and fresh grain character that belies its substantial proof. (00:16:52)
  • Lost Lantern New York Distilling Company 10 Year Old Straight Rye: Single cask, cask strength at 66.9% ABV (133.8 proof) from New York Distilling Company in Brooklyn, New York. Mash bill of 72% rye, 16% corn, and 12% malted barley. Considered one of the oldest New York whiskeys ever released, this Brooklyn rye swings to a darker, more brooding register — dark chocolate, leather, dried fruit, and well-integrated oak on both the nose and palate, rounded out by that characteristically rich, velvety mouthfeel. (00:27:09)
  • Lost Lantern Westland 9.99 Year Old American Single Malt (Peated, Scottish Peat): Single cask at 54.9% ABV (109.8 proof) from Westland Distillery in Seattle, Washington. 100% malted barley peated with Scottish peat — a now-discontinued style predating Westland's shift to Washington peat. Bottled the day before its tenth birthday to preserve Westland's right to release their own first 10-year-old. Smoke is present but not dominant, layered over scorched apple, orchard fruit, cinnamon, and a savory, grilled-meat character from the oak influence of new American barrels. (00:37:01)

Adam shares the origin story of Lost Lantern — born out of a shared frustration with a lack of transparency in craft whiskey sourcing — and explains the rigorous process he and co-founder Nora Ganley-Roper use to evaluate barrels: always visiting distilleries in person before buying, never selecting on-site, and requiring unanimous agreement before any purchase. He also touches on the brand's Single Distillery and Blend series, their Vermont tasting room, and tantalizing hints at an unconventional Spring 2025 collection. Whether you're a lifelong bourbon devotee or a curious explorer ready to venture beyond Kentucky, this episode makes a compelling case that world-class American whiskey is being made from Brooklyn to Brooklyn Park to the banks of Lake Erie — and Lost Lantern is the guide to find it.

Full Transcript

Adam Polanski Tasting Craft Distillery Visit Bourbon Rye Single Malt Cask Strength Small Batch Kentucky Ohio Thomas Foolery Distillery Spirit Works Distillery Lantern New York Distilling New York Distilling Westland Distillery Single Distillery Lost Lantern Lost Lantern Whiskey Adam Polanski Thomas Foolery Distillery Spirit Works Distillery New York Distilling Company Westland Distillery independent bottler American single malt peated whiskey craft bourbon Ohio bourbon California rye Brooklyn rye single cask whiskey cask strength bourbon American whiskey craft distillery whiskey sourcing 10 year bourbon The Bourbon Road podcast