Skip to content
Episode 421 December 4, 2024 · 51:55
421. Lost Lantern Whiskey

421. Lost Lantern Whiskey

Adam Polanski of Lost Lantern Whiskey joins Todd to taste 4 single casks: a 10yr Ohio bourbon, 2 cool-climate ryes (CA & NY), and a peated WA single malt.

The Bourbon Road Media Player

Reviews

Show Notes

Todd Ritter flies solo this week while Jim Shannon enjoys some Florida sunshine, welcoming Adam Polanski — co-founder and head of whiskey sourcing for Lost Lantern Whiskey — to the show. Lost Lantern is an independent bottler modeled on the storied Scottish tradition of independent bottling, sourcing single casks and small batches from craft distilleries across the United States and releasing them with full transparency about their origins. Adam walks us through the philosophy behind the company, the road-trip-fueled distillery-visit requirement before any barrel purchase, and the meticulous blind-tasting process he and co-founder Nora use to select every cask.

On the Tasting Mat:

  • Lost Lantern Thomas Foolery 10 Year Old Ohio Straight Bourbon (Single Cask): A cask-strength, non-chill-filtered single barrel at 59.7% ABV from Thomas Foolery Distillery near Lake Erie in Ohio. The mash bill is 63% corn, 10% rye, and 27% malted barley. The cooler, lake-influenced climate produces a bourbon with notable depth — expect maple syrup, green apple, dark fruit, dark chocolate, and a rich vanilla character throughout. (00:03:54)
  • Lost Lantern Spirit Works Distillery 10 Year Old California Straight Rye (Single Cask): Bottled at a bold 69.6% ABV from the female-led Spirit Works Distillery in Sebastopol, Sonoma County, California. The mash bill is 70% rye, 10% malted rye, and 20% malted barley. The maritime, wine-country climate lends a distinctly fruity and floral character — bright citrus, lemon meringue, and a lively spearmint spice with a velvety mouthfeel that belies its proof. (00:16:52)
  • Lost Lantern New York Distilling Company 10 Year Old New York Straight Rye (Single Cask): A 66.9% ABV single cask from the pioneering New York Distilling Company in Brooklyn, New York — potentially one of the oldest New York whiskeys ever released. The mash bill is 72% rye, 16% corn, and 12% malted barley. The cooler East Coast climate yields a darker, more brooding profile: rich dark chocolate, leather, dried dark fruit, and a satisfying oak backbone, all delivered with a smooth, velvety texture. (00:27:09)
  • Lost Lantern Westland Distillery 9.99 Year Old American Single Malt (Peated, Single Cask): Bottled at 54.9% ABV and deliberately drawn the day before its tenth birthday, this single cask from Westland Distillery in Seattle, Washington is made from 100% malted barley peated with Scottish peat — a style Westland has since retired in favor of Pacific Northwest peat. Aged in new American oak barrels, it delivers campfire smoke alongside scorched apple, orchard fruit, cinnamon, a savory roasted-meat quality, and rich dark color. (00:37:01)

Adam shares a behind-the-scenes look at what it takes to build a transparent, craft-focused independent bottling company from scratch, including the road trip that started it all, the discipline of tasting samples in silence before comparing notes, and a tease of what Lost Lantern has planned for their fifth-anniversary spring 2025 collection. Whether you are a bourbon devotee, a rye enthusiast, or a peated single malt lover, this episode is a reminder that world-class American whiskey is being made far beyond the borders of Kentucky.

Full Transcript

Lost Lantern Whiskey Adam Polanski independent bottler Thomas Foolery Distillery Spirit Works Distillery New York Distilling Company Westland Distillery Ohio bourbon California rye New York rye peated American single malt craft whiskey single cask cask strength American single malt bourbon trail craft distillery Todd Ritter fall 2024 collection transparent sourcing

The Conversation