Skip to content
Episode 438 April 2, 2025 · 01:38:31
438. Blind Barrels

438. Blind Barrels

Bobby DeMars of Blind Barrels guides Jim & Todd through a fully double-blind tasting of Chambers Bay, Whiskey Acres, Iowa Legendary Rye, and Mythology Distillery.

The Bourbon Road Media Player

Tasting Notes

Show Notes

Jim Shannon and Todd Ritter welcome Bobby DeMars, founder of Blind Barrels, to the show for a fully double-blind tasting experience. Blind Barrels is a quarterly subscription service that sources exceptional American craft whiskeys — unknown to the recipient — and ships them in beautifully packaged kits of four 50 mL samples. Bobby walks Jim and Todd through the concept, the curation philosophy, and the legal gymnastics required to pull it all off, while the hosts nose, sip, and guess their way through four genuinely surprising pours from distilleries most listeners have never encountered.

On the Tasting Mat:

  • Chambers Bay Blue Label Straight Bourbon Whiskey: A four-year, 95-proof wheated bourbon from Puget Sound, Washington, built on a 70% sweet yellow corn, 20% soft white wheat, and 10% barley mash bill. Aged in a rick house situated on a floating barge in Puget Sound, the whiskey delivers green apple, cinnamon, butterscotch, fresh grain, and saltwater taffy on the nose, with honey wheat bread, sea-salted caramel, yellow birthday cake, and green apple pie on the palate, finishing with candied orange peel and toasted oak. (00:24:06)
  • Whiskey Acres Bottled-in-Bond Bourbon: A five-year, 100-proof bourbon from DeKalb, Illinois, made by true seed-to-bottle farmers who engineer their own grain varieties. The mash bill is 75% dent corn, 15% soft red winter wheat, and 10% malted barley. Rich aromas of vanilla, herbal tea, lemongrass, cinnamon, nutty oak, and graham crackers give way to caramel corn, grassy notes, pear drops, raw hazelnuts, dark wood, lightly toasted coconut, apple cider donuts, and ripe orchard apples on the palate, with a finish of red berries fading into peppery spice. (00:37:38)
  • Iowa Legendary Rye Gold Label: A non-age-stated, 105-proof prohibition-era recipe rye from Carroll, Iowa, made with only bread rye, water, yeast, and cane sugar — a blend of the distillery's black, red, and purple label expressions. Rooted in the bootlegging legacy of the founder's grandmother, who was reputedly Al Capone's favorite supplier, the spirit delivers maple donut, Werther's Original, thyme, turbinado sugar, aromatic bitters, and buttered bread on the nose, with melted caramel, cinnamon, orange studded with nutmeg, deep oak, and baked oats on the palate, finishing with leather and black pepper. (00:59:06)
  • Mythology Distillery Man's Best Friend Cask Strength Bourbon: A 118-proof cask strength bourbon from Steamboat Springs, Colorado, blending a 15-year Kentucky bourbon, a 5-year Indiana bourbon, and a 3-year Indiana bourbon. The nose opens with peanut brittle, light herbs, cornbread, and wildflower honey, while the palate delivers rich caramel, candied almonds, oak, toasted grains, strawberry frosting, cherry, pipe tobacco, and peanut dust. The finish is long and decadent with vanilla bean, crème brûlée, and black currant. (01:11:25)

Bobby DeMars makes a compelling case that the best way to discover great whiskey is to remove every label, price tag, and preconception from the equation. Whether you are a seasoned enthusiast or just beginning your whiskey journey, Blind Barrels offers a genuinely unique way to expand your palate and support small American distilleries you would never find on your own. Visit blindbarrels.com and use code WHISKY10 for 10% off any purchase, and new members receive a free tasting glass with their first kit.

Full Transcript

Bobby DeMars Tasting Bottled in Bond Interview Craft Distillery Visit Bourbon Wheated Cask Strength Bottled in Bond Kentucky Indiana Colorado Mythology Distillery Blind Barrels Bobby DeMars craft whiskey double blind tasting Chambers Bay Whiskey Acres Iowa Legendary Rye Mythology Distillery bourbon subscription American craft distillery wheated bourbon bottled in bond cask strength bourbon prohibition rye Puget Sound whiskey DeKalb Illinois bourbon Colorado bourbon whiskey subscription box small batch bourbon craft whiskey discovery