Skip to content
Episode 443 May 7, 2025 · 48:32
443. The Great Divide: Bourbon, Barrel Picks, and Beyond

443. The Great Divide: Bourbon, Barrel Picks, and Beyond

Jim's in Colorado, Todd's in Kentucky — Woodford Derby, Penelope Architect, 291 Maple Rye M, and Pikesville Rye are in the glasses.

The Bourbon Road Media Player

Reviews

Show Notes

Jim Shannon is calling in from Colorado Springs while co-host Todd Ritter holds down the fort in Kentucky, and together they prove that a little distance is no obstacle to a great pour. The guys catch up on Derby week adventures — including Jim's mint julep duties at a Colorado Derby party and a surprise exacta win — before diving into the latest bourbon industry news: the Wild Turkey 8-Year 101 hitting shelves at $49, the debut of Lost Lantern's monthly subscription service, a new EH Taylor addition to the Buffalo Trace Antique Collection, Whiskey Thief's hazmat 2025 Mayday Rye at 146 proof, and the buzz around so-called "Buff Turkey" single barrel picks. Jim also teases an upcoming on-site visit and tasting at Laws Whiskey House in Denver.

The pair also reflect on a recent barrel pick at the James E. Pepper Distillery in Lexington for Bourbon on the Banks, the upcoming premiere of the Frankfort Bourbon Documentary (narrated by Todd) on June 13th at The Foundry, and the broader state of the bourbon market — from festival sellouts to industry layoffs and the surging RTD and THC beverage categories.

On the Tasting Mat:

  • Woodford Reserve Distiller's Select 2025 Kentucky Derby Bottle: The annual limited-edition Derby release from Woodford Reserve clocks in at 90.4 proof. Classic and approachable, this expression carries all the hallmarks of the flagship Woodford — rich vanilla, dried fruit, and warm oak — dressed up in collector-worthy Derby artwork. Jim brought a bottle out to Colorado for the Derby party and cracked it open for the show. (00:03:17)
  • Penelope Bourbon Architect Series (3rd Edition): Sourced from MGP and finished in French oak staves, this straight bourbon comes in at 104 proof and retails around $65. Todd notes the MGP character comes through clearly — ripe cherry up front — while the French oak adds a distinctive, slightly funky wood character on the finish. (00:04:10)
  • 291 Colorado Rye Whiskey "M" — Aspen Wood Staves & Maple Syrup Barrel Finish: The big second-half pour from Jim's Colorado travels, this expression from Distillery 291 in Colorado Springs weighs in at a hefty 122 proof. True to the 291 house style — easy to identify in a blind pour — it delivers a prominent maple sweetness from the barrel finish, layered over the brand's distinctively spicy and characterful Colorado rye base. (00:24:48)
  • Pikesville Straight Rye Whiskey: Todd's second-half pour is this Heaven Hill classic — a six-year-old, 51% rye mash bill Maryland-style rye bottled at 110 proof for around $50. Silky and approachable, it draws on the same mash bill as Rittenhouse and Elijah Craig Rye but delivers a richer, more mature expression thanks to its age and proof point. (00:27:00)

From Colorado to Kentucky, Jim and Todd wrap up another honest, wide-ranging conversation about where bourbon is, where it's headed, and why the community around it remains as strong as ever. Look for Jim's Laws Whiskey House episode coming soon, and if you're near Frankfort on June 13th, don't miss the premiere of the Frankfort Bourbon Documentary — with donations going to local flood relief.

Full Transcript

Woodford Reserve Derby bottle Penelope Bourbon Architect 291 Colorado Rye Pikesville Rye Heaven Hill MGP sourced bourbon Wild Turkey 8 Year 101 Lost Lantern whiskey subscription Buffalo Trace Antique Collection EH Taylor James E Pepper Distillery Whiskey Thief Mayday Rye Bourbon on the Banks Festival Frankfort Bourbon Documentary Laws Whiskey House Denver French oak finish maple barrel finish rye whiskey Colorado whiskey bourbon news 2025

The Conversation