Skip to content
Episode 443 May 7, 2025 · 48:32
443. The Great Divide: Bourbon, Barrel Picks, and Beyond

443. The Great Divide: Bourbon, Barrel Picks, and Beyond

Jim's in Colorado, Todd's in Kentucky—Woodford Derby bottle, Penelope Architect, 291 Colorado Rye "M", and Pikesville Rye are on the mat.

The Bourbon Road Media Player

Tasting Notes

Show Notes

Jim Shannon is calling in from Colorado Springs while Todd Ritter holds down the fort in Kentucky, and the two hosts prove that a little geography never gets in the way of good conversation or good whiskey. This week's episode is a wide-ranging check-in covering Derby Day adventures, industry news, upcoming events, and a pair of pours on each side of the Great Divide.

On the Tasting Mat:

  • Woodford Reserve Distiller's Select Kentucky Derby Bottle 2025: The annual Derby release from Woodford Reserve, bottled at 90.4 proof. A classic, traditional Woodford profile featuring the familiar notes of vanilla, dried fruit, and balanced oak that have made this expression a perennial crowd-pleaser. Jim brought this bottle to a Derby party in Colorado Springs, where it was shared with around 30 guests. (00:03:17)
  • Penelope Bourbon Architect Series (Third Edition): An MGP-sourced straight bourbon finished in French oak staves, bottled at 104 proof and retailing around $65. Todd notes a cherry-forward character typical of MGP distillate, with the French oak finish lending a distinctive, slightly funky oak quality to the palate. (00:03:54)
  • 291 Colorado Rye Whiskey "M" — Aspen Wood Staves & Maple Syrup Barrel Finish: Bottled at a robust 122 proof, this expression from 291 Distillery in Colorado Springs showcases the distillery's unmistakably unique house profile, elevated by a pronounced maple syrup sweetness from the barrel finish. Jim notes that no matter the expression, 291's signature character always shines through. (00:24:48)
  • Pikesville Straight Rye Whiskey: Heaven Hill's aged Maryland-style rye, bottled at 110 proof and retailing around $50. A six-year-old rye built on a 51% rye mash bill, offering an approachable, easy-sipping character that Todd credits as one of the best values on the shelf in its category. (00:27:00)

Beyond the pours, Jim and Todd cover a lot of ground: the exciting upcoming interview with Laws Whiskey House in Denver, the Bourbon on the Banks Festival on October 4th in Frankfort, the release of Wild Turkey's new 8-Year 101, the Whiskey Thief's 2025 Mayday Rye at 146 proof, the addition of an EH Taylor expression to the Buffalo Trace Antique Collection, the buzz around "Buff Turkey" barrel picks, and Bo Cumberland's Frankfurt Bourbon documentary premiering June 13th at The Foundry. Whether you're sipping along from Kentucky or Colorado, there's plenty to enjoy on this week's Bourbon Road.

Full Transcript

Tasting Bourbon Rye Finished Kentucky Colorado Heaven Hill Buffalo Trace Wild Turkey Woodford Reserve MGP Woodford Reserve Penelope Bourbon 291 Colorado Rye Pikesville Rye Heaven Hill MGP Wild Turkey 8 Year Buffalo Trace Antique Collection EH Taylor Laws Whiskey House James Pepper Distillery Bourbon on the Banks Festival Whiskey Thief Distillery Mayday Rye Buff Turkey Dark Arts Distillery Frankfort bourbon documentary barrel pick ready to drink cocktails Colorado whiskey