Skip to content
Episode 460 September 3, 2025 · 48:13
460. Ranking the Titans: Old Forester Birthday vs. Bardstown Hokkaido

460. Ranking the Titans: Old Forester Birthday vs. Bardstown Hokkaido

Jim & Todd taste Old Forester Birthday Bourbon 2025, Penelope Cigar Sessions, Bardstown Hokkaido Mizunara, and Jefferson's Reserve Cask Strength.

The Bourbon Road Media Player

Tasting Notes

Show Notes

Jim Shannon and Todd Ritter are back in the Corner Rickhouse with the Frankfort Bourbon Society for a four-bottle sample review show that spans some of the most talked-about pours of the season. From a sweetly unexpected Birthday Bourbon release to a cigar-forward American whiskey blend, a jaw-dropping Mizunara-finished blend loaded with aged Kentucky juice, and a cask-strength Jefferson's that punches well above its weight, this episode is a masterclass in the diversity Kentucky — and beyond — has to offer right now.

On the Tasting Mat:

  • Old Forester Birthday Bourbon 2025: A 12-year-old Kentucky straight bourbon clocking in at a surprisingly soft 92 proof, distilled as sweet mash — a rare departure for Old Forester. Selected by emeritus distiller Chris Morris and assistant master distiller Caleb Trigo from warehouse K, floors one through five. The nose opens with oakey cherry and walnut, while the palate delivers a lush wave of bright cherry, hints of bubblegum, and a finish that drinks well above its proof. Released in honor of founder George Garvin Brown around September 2nd. MSRP ~$199.99 / 750ml. (00:11:01)
  • Penelope Cigar Sessions: A 101-proof American whiskey blend designed to complement a medium-bodied cigar, combining Kentucky straight bourbon, American single malt, and American light whiskey — with a reported six-year age statement — at an MSRP of $79.99. The nose offers a curious interplay of cotton candy, chocolate, and stewed fruits, while the palate turns decidedly stone-fruit-forward: candied peach on the grill, a big sweetness, and a single-malt backbone that shines through on the finish. Crafted in partnership with cigar industry figures and released as Batch One of an ongoing series. (00:25:29)
  • Bardstown Bourbon Company Hokkaido Mizunara Oak Barrel Finish: A 109.3-proof blend of four distinct straight whiskeys — a 47% Kentucky 15-year (75/13/8/12 mash bill), a 33% Kentucky 14-year (78/10/12), a 15% Indiana 9-year rye (45/51/4), and a 5% Tennessee 18-year (84/8/8) — finished for 28 months in Japanese Mizunara oak barrels. The nose opens with savory new leather and a whisper of sassafras spice, while the palate layers buttery richness, Danish butter cookie sweetness, baked pear, and a dancing oak spice that never overwhelms. A 375ml release. (00:41:39)
  • Jefferson's Reserve Cask Strength: A 130-proof, approximately 8-year-old Kentucky straight bourbon believed to be Jefferson's own distillate — their first non-ocean cask-strength release — retailing for around $70. The nose blooms with cherry blossoms and a bright floral lift, with just enough ethanol presence to remind you of the proof. On the palate it is rich and sweet, delivering vivid maraschino cherry, amaretto, toasted nuttiness, and a warm interplay of new and mature oak that lingers through a long finish. (00:33:53)

Four remarkable pours, four distinct stories — sweet mash experimentation, cigar culture crossovers, the magic of Mizunara, and a cask-strength homecoming. Whether you are hunting down a Birthday Bourbon lottery win or scooping a Jefferson's Reserve off a well-stocked shelf, this episode gives you everything you need to know before you pour. Cheers, roadies — we'll see you down the Bourbon Road.

Full Transcript

Tasting Head-to-Head Bourbon Single Malt Cask Strength Kentucky Tennessee Indiana Old Forester Bardstown Bourbon Company Old Forester Birthday Bourbon Penelope Cigar Sessions Bardstown Bourbon Company Jefferson's Reserve Cask Strength Mizunara oak sweet mash bourbon American single malt Kentucky straight bourbon cask strength bourbon Frankfort Bourbon Society Brown-Forman MGP Jefferson's Ocean barrel finish cigar pairing whiskey aged bourbon rare bourbon limited release bourbon Kentucky whiskey sample review