Skip to content
Episode 470 November 19, 2025 · 46:06
470. Jim Returns for a Winner Winner Chicken Dinner

470. Jim Returns for a Winner Winner Chicken Dinner

Jim returns to the Cornrick House as he and Todd sip Burnt Tavern, Gypsy "The Declaration," Bourbon Pursuit Kodama Mizunara, and Old Anvil 11-Year.

The Bourbon Road Media Player

Tasting Notes

Show Notes

Jim Shannon is back at the Cornrick House in Frankfort, Kentucky, joining host Todd Ritter for a four-bottle review show packed with unique expressions and fascinating backstories. Before diving into the glasses, the guys catch up on last week's solo episode — Todd's read-through of an E.H. Taylor essay — and geek out on colonial-era bourbon history, the mystery of Lester Easter Day, and whether James Crow ever held a doctorate. With samples lined up from a whisper-smoked Kentucky newcomer, a colonial-era rye reimagination, and two exclusive releases from the Bourbon Pursuit crew, this one earns its winner-winner-chicken-dinner subtitle.

On the Tasting Mat:

  • Burnt Tavern Bourbon: A 7-year-old Kentucky straight bourbon bottled at 105 proof, double-barreled in slowly toasted and charred secondary barrels under the guidance of master distiller Chip Tate. The nose opens with smoky cherries and caramel, while the palate delivers a quick rush of sweetness followed by persistent oak and a genuine whisper of sweet barbecue smoke. Retails for $69.99. (00:04:13)
  • Gypsy Spirits Legacy Batch 003 "The Declaration": A limited-edition blend bottled at 115.74 proof paying tribute to America's 250th anniversary. The recipe combines 60% 8–12-year-old 95/5 Indiana rye finished in apple brandy barrels sourced from George Washington's Mount Vernon Distillery, 30% 20–25-year-old Canadian corn whiskey re-barreled in new American oak for two and a half years, and 10% 8-year-old American single malt from Virginia. The nose is remarkably restrained for the proof, with fresh mint and subtle oak; the palate delivers Mexican chocolate, white pepper, rich caramel, and a long, sticky finish that rewards patience. Retails for $199.99. (00:12:00)
  • Bourbon Pursuit United Kodama Mizunara Finish: A barrel-proof expression at 117 proof blending 80% Mizunara-finished bourbon with 20% Pursuit's regular Kentucky/Virginia/New York blend. "Kodama" means spirit of the trees in Japanese, and the pour lives up to its name — a forest-fresh, floral nose with hints of cherry blossom gives way to a bright, savory palate with green apple, caramel, and a distinctive viscosity that drinks well below its proof. Available exclusively at the Bourbon Pursuit gift shop in Louisville for $89.99. (00:24:14)
  • Bourbon Pursuit Old Anvil 11-Year (375 mL): A barrel-proof Kentucky straight bourbon at 119.4 proof, distilled from a one-off Heaven Hill mash bill of 70/21/9 corn/rye/malt. The barrels were acquired at five years old, deemed underwhelming, and held for six more years before bottling — a decision that paid off handsomely. The nose offers rich fruit, caramel, and an evocative wet-limestone minerality; the palate brings vanilla cream, crème brûlée, coconut, and a big, chewy mid-palate presence. Roughly four cases remained at the Louisville gift shop at time of recording; $99.99 for a 375 mL pint. (00:30:18)

The episode closes with Jim doing what he does — combining leftover pours into a spontaneous house blend that somehow works beautifully, the burnt tavern smoke threading through the gypsy sweetness and the mizunara savoriness. Four bottles, four distinct personalities, and zero duds. Whether you're hunting for a gift, planning a stop on Whiskey Row, or just looking for your next bottle, this episode hands you a well-curated shortlist.

Full Transcript

Tasting Bourbon Single Malt Finished Kentucky Indiana Virginia Mount Vernon Distillery Heaven Hill Burnt Tavern Bourbon Chip Tate Gypsy Spirits The Declaration Bourbon Pursuit Kodama Mizunara Old Anvil Heaven Hill Mizunara oak finish Kentucky straight bourbon barrel proof bourbon rye whiskey apple brandy finish Mount Vernon Distillery Canadian corn whiskey American single malt whiskey blending Frankfort Kentucky Bourbon Road podcast Jim Shannon Todd Ritter