Skip to content
Episode 470 November 19, 2025 · 46:06
470. Jim Returns for a Winner Winner Chicken Dinner

470. Jim Returns for a Winner Winner Chicken Dinner

Burnt Tavern, Gypsy Declaration Batch 003, Pursuit Kodama Mizunara & Old Anvil 11-Year on the mat in Frankfort — four very different bottles, one great night.

The Bourbon Road Media Player

Reviews

Show Notes

Jim Shannon and Todd Ritter are back together at the Cornrick House in Frankfort, Kentucky for a four-bottle review episode that spans new craft producers, ambitious blends, and some serious barrel-finishing wizardry. Before diving into the glasses, the guys briefly revisit last week's solo episode — Todd's reading of an E.H. Taylor essay — and marvel at Taylor's gift for promoting Kentucky bourbon to the world. Then it's time to pour.

On the Tasting Mat:

  • Burnt Tavern Bourbon: A 7-year-old Kentucky straight bourbon bottled at 105 proof, double-barreled through two slowly toasted and charred secondary barrels under the watch of master distiller Chip Tate, formerly of Balcones. The nose opens with smoky cherries and caramel, evoking a cherries flambé, while the palate delivers a rush of sweetness quickly followed by bold oak. A whisper of sweet smoke — think Kansas City barbecue — winds through from nose to finish, giving this expression a genuinely distinctive personality without veering into peaty territory. Retails around $69.99. (00:04:13)
  • Gypsy Spirits The Declaration (Legacy Batch 003): The third limited-edition release from the brand co-founded by country artist Eric Church and entrepreneur Raj Alva, bottled at 115.74 proof. The blend pays tribute to the upcoming 250th anniversary of the Declaration of Independence and reimagines a colonial-era Maryland-style rye. It combines 60% of an 8–12-year-old 95/5 Indiana rye finished in apple brandy barrels sourced from George Washington's Mount Vernon Distillery, 30% of a 20–25-year-old Canadian corn whiskey re-barreled in new American oak for two and a half years, and 10% of an 8-year-old American single malt from Virginia. The nose is remarkably composed for the proof — balanced and inviting — while the palate rewards patience with Mexican chocolate, white pepper, rich caramel, and a long, sticky finish. Retails at $199.99. (00:12:27)
  • Pursuit United Kodama Mizunara Finish: A barrel-proof expression bottled at 117 proof from Bourbon Pursuit Spirits, blending 80% Mizunara oak-finished whiskey with 20% of the brand's regular blend of sourced Kentucky, Virginia, and New York bourbons. "Kodama" means "spirit of the trees" in Japanese. The nose is strikingly fresh and floral — cherry blossoms, a garden walk — with none of the heat expected from the proof. On the palate it is simultaneously savory and bright, with green apple, rich caramel, and a front-of-the-tongue warmth that lingers without aggression. One of the most elegant Mizunara finishes Jim and Todd have encountered. Retails at $89.99, available exclusively at the Bourbon Pursuit gift shop in Louisville. (00:26:14)
  • Pursuit United Old Anvil (11 Summers, 375ml): An 11-year-old Kentucky straight bourbon bottled at barrel proof — 119.4 proof — distilled from a one-off Heaven Hill mash bill of 70% corn, 21% rye, and 9% malt. Kenny Coleman of Bourbon Pursuit acquired the barrels at five years old, waited six more years for the whiskey to come into its own, and the result is something that defies easy categorization. The nose hints at wet limestone and rich fruit, while the palate delivers vanilla cream, crème brûlée, a touch of coconut, and a depth that recalls a great ECBP without being a copy of one. Only a handful of cases remain at the Louisville gift shop. Retails at $99.99 for a 375ml bottle. (00:30:24)

The episode closes with Jim's now-legendary tradition of combining the remnants of all four pours into a single glass — and this time the experiment lands beautifully. The burnt tavern smoke carries through, the Gypsy's sweetness blooms, the Mizunara lends its savory backbone, and the Old Anvil anchors the whole thing. Four remarkably distinct expressions, each worth seeking out on their own terms.

Full Transcript

Burnt Tavern Bourbon Chip Tate Gypsy Spirits Eric Church Gypsy Declaration Bourbon Pursuit Pursuit United Kodama Mizunara Old Anvil Kentucky straight bourbon Mizunara oak double barrel barrel proof Heaven Hill Maryland rye apple brandy finish whiskey blending Frankfort Kentucky bourbon review craft bourbon

The Conversation