Skip to content
Episode 471 November 26, 2025 · 57:53
471. The Sample Safe: Unlocking Lost Lantern's Fall 2025 Collection

471. The Sample Safe: Unlocking Lost Lantern's Fall 2025 Collection

Jim & Todd taste 7 Lost Lantern Fall 2025 American single malts: Warfield Idaho, Triple Eight Nantucket, McCarthy's Oregon, and two vatted blends.

The Bourbon Road Media Player

Reviews

Show Notes

Jim Shannon and Todd Ritter are back with a laser-focused tasting session built entirely around Lost Lantern's 2025 Fall Collection — seven American single malts that collectively map the breadth and ambition of the American single malt category. From delicately blended vatted expressions to cask-strength solo barrels aged on a Massachusetts island and peated outliers smoked with Scottish Highland peat, this episode is a deep dive into what American craft distillers are doing with malted barley. Todd assembled the lineup from the sample safe, and the pair work their way through each pour with characteristic curiosity, debating maritime salinity, campfire oak smoke, lemon-square butter crusts, and the surprising elegance hiding inside a 135-proof Idaho malt.

On the Tasting Mat:

  • Lost Lantern American Vatted Malt Reissue: A fifth-anniversary recreation of Lost Lantern's very first whiskey, blending single malts from Balcones, Copperworks, Santa Fe Spirits, Triple Eight, Westward, and Virginia Distillery Company. Bottled at 105 proof with ages ranging from two to seven years, MSRP $90. The nose opens with honey, baked pear, and honey-nut cereal; the palate is sweet and fruit-forward with light caramel and fresh oak, finishing cleanly with an aromatic, jam-like fruit quality. (00:04:07)
  • Lost Lantern American Vatted Malt Remix: The original six-distillery blend expanded to eleven components by adding Andalusia, Cedar Ridge, McCarthy's, Westland, and Whiskey Del Bac. Bottled at 110.7 proof, two to eight years old, MSRP $100. The nose shifts toward darker, stewed fruits with less pronounced cereal; the palate is more assertive, delivering candied orange, golden raisin, a touch of black licorice and anise, with a drying, leathery finish that lingers noticeably longer. (00:10:22)
  • Lost Lantern Warfield American Single Malt (4 Year): A single barrel from Warfield Distillery in Ketchum, Idaho — one of the few American distilleries using traditional fourth-size Scottish pot stills and one of the country's only certified organic distilleries. 100% malted barley aged four years in ex-bourbon casks, bottled at 135.4 proof, 196 bottles, MSRP $100. The nose offers lemon zest, wet stone minerality, and a subtle sour citrus note; the palate surprises with a creamy, buttery texture, lemon-square richness, and a grassy brightness that departs entirely from the nose. (00:17:51)
  • Lost Lantern Triple Eight 10 Year Single Malt: Hand-selected from Triple Eight Distillery on Nantucket, Massachusetts, made with 100% Maris Otter malt from East Anglia, UK, aged ten years in ex-bourbon barrels. Bottled at 124.2 proof, 174 bottles, MSRP $150. The nose presents orchard fruit, bubble gum, and a whisper of ethanol; the palate opens with notable salinity — a maritime brine character consistent with Nantucket's coastal climate — alongside caramel apple, butterscotch, and a long, fruit-rich finish. (00:24:34)
  • Lost Lantern Triple Eight 11 Year Sauternes Cask Single Malt: The oldest whiskey Lost Lantern has ever released and the brand's first expression fully matured in ex-Sauternes casks — French oak, 11 years, Maris Otter malt. Bottled at 120.9 proof, 229 bottles, MSRP $180. Deep mahogany in the glass; the nose carries old French oak funk, golden raisin, and a nutty almond quality. The palate is concentrated and syrupy, delivering honey-roasted almonds, fig, and a richness reminiscent of a tawny port-finished whisky. (00:30:44)
  • Lost Lantern Triple Eight 10 Year Peated Single Malt: Triple Eight's 100% Maris Otter malt smoked with peat from the Scottish Highlands, aged six and a half years in ex-bourbon barrels. Bottled at 115.9 proof, 196 bottles, MSRP $120. The nose is immediately medicinal and iodine-forward with a coastal brine note and apricot lurking beneath; the palate is velvety and buttery, with the peat landing more as an elegant medicinal wash rather than an overpowering smoke, balanced by stone fruit sweetness on the finish. (00:35:39)
  • Lost Lantern McCarthy's 10 Year Peated Single Malt: A hand-selected cask from Clear Creek Distillery's McCarthy's American Single Malt in Hood River, Oregon — widely considered the first American single malt ever produced. Aged ten years in a 400-liter fourth-fill Oregon Gariana oak cask. Bottled at 118.6 proof, 250 bottles, MSRP $150. The nose presents a darker, savory smoke — oak campfire rather than medicinal peat — with hints of burnt tire and dark fruit. The palate delivers blueberry cobbler, leather, and a rich campfire-smoke character, with the fruit deepening into blackberry territory on a long, satisfying finish. (00:40:41)

Lost Lantern continues to be one of the most compelling independent bottlers in the American whiskey landscape, and this fall collection makes a compelling case that American single malt deserves a permanent seat at any serious whiskey enthusiast's table. Whether you're drawn to the approachable sweetness of the vatted expressions, the coastal complexity of a decade-old Nantucket malt, or the campfire allure of a century-old Oregon recipe, there is something here worth seeking out. Check availability directly at lostlanternwhiskey.com, and if you're local to Vermont, the tasting room is well worth the trip.

Full Transcript

Lost Lantern American single malt Warfield Distillery Triple Eight Distillery McCarthy's Clear Creek Distillery Balcones Copperworks Westland Cedar Ridge Virginia Distillery Company Andalusia Whiskey vatted malt peated whiskey Nantucket whiskey Idaho distillery Oregon whiskey craft distillery independent bottler Maris Otter malt

The Conversation