Skip to content
Episode 471 November 26, 2025 · 57:53
471. The Sample Safe: Unlocking Lost Lantern's Fall 2025 Collection

471. The Sample Safe: Unlocking Lost Lantern's Fall 2025 Collection

Jim & Todd taste all 7 bottles from Lost Lantern's Fall 2025 Collection — Warfield Idaho, Triple Eight Nantucket, McCarthy's Oregon, and two vatted malts.

The Bourbon Road Media Player

Tasting Notes

Show Notes

Jim Shannon and Todd Ritter reach into the sample safe for a focused deep-dive into Lost Lantern's Fall 2025 Collection — seven American single malts sourced from craft distilleries across the country. From vatted blends celebrating Lost Lantern's fifth anniversary to rare single-barrel releases from Idaho and Massachusetts, this episode is a passport tour of what American single malt whiskey has become.

On the Tasting Mat:

  • Lost Lantern American Vatted Malt Reissue: A fifth-anniversary recreation of Lost Lantern's very first whiskey, blending single malts from Balcones, Copperworks, Santa Fe Spirits, Triple Eight, Westward, and Virginia Distillery Company. 105 proof, ages 2–7 years, ~500 bottles, MSRP $90. Delicate and honey-sweet on both nose and palate with notes of honey, pear jam, and toasted cereal. (00:10:07)
  • Lost Lantern American Vatted Malt Remix: The original six-distillery vatted malt expanded with contributions from Andalusia, Cedar Ridge, McCarthy's, Westland, and Whiskey Del Bac — eleven single malts in total. 110.7 proof, ages 2–8 years, ~800 bottles, MSRP $100. The palate shifts darker and spicier, offering golden raisins, candied orange, anise, leather, and a longer drying finish. (00:22:42)
  • Warfield American Single Malt (Lost Lantern Single Barrel): A single barrel from Warfield Distillery in Ketchum, Idaho — one of the country's only certified organic distilleries, using traditional Scottish pot stills. 135.4 proof, 4 years old, 196 bottles, MSRP $100. The nose brings lemon zest and wet stone minerality; the palate transforms into a lush, creamy lemon square — buttery shortbread crust, powdered sugar sweetness, and a grassy finish. (00:32:50)
  • Triple Eight 10 Year Single Malt (Lost Lantern Single Barrel): Hand-selected from Triple Eight Distillery on Nantucket, Massachusetts, made with 100% Maris Otter malt from East Anglia, UK, aged in ex-bourbon barrels. 124.2 proof, 10 years, 174 bottles, MSRP $150. Notes of orchard fruit, caramel apple, bubble gum, butterscotch, and a distinctive maritime salinity that likely reflects Nantucket's coastal environment. (00:40:27)
  • Triple Eight 11 Year Sauternes Cask Single Malt (Lost Lantern Single Barrel): The oldest whiskey Lost Lantern has ever released — fully matured for 11 years in ex-Sauternes French oak casks. 120.9 proof, 229 bottles, MSRP $180. Deep mahogany in color; the nose evokes an aged wine cellar with golden raisins and almonds, while the palate is rich, concentrated, and syrupy with honey-roasted nuts and figgy dried fruit. (00:50:30)
  • Triple Eight 10 Year Peated Single Malt (Lost Lantern Single Barrel): Triple Eight's 100% Maris Otter malt smoked with Scottish Highland peat, aged 6½ years in ex-bourbon barrels. 115.9 proof, 196 bottles, MSRP $120. The nose leads with medicinal iodine and apricot; the palate is surprisingly velvety and well-restrained, with a creamy texture, coastal brine, and a clean iodine finish. (00:58:37)
  • McCarthy's 10 Year Peated Single Malt (Lost Lantern Single Barrel): A hand-selected cask from Clear Creek Distillery in Hood River, Oregon — home of McCarthy's, considered the first American single malt. Aged 10 years in a 400-liter fourth-fill Oregon Gariana oak cask. 118.6 proof, 250 bottles, MSRP $150. The nose offers dark, savory campfire smoke and a hint of burnt wood; the palate is complex with blueberry cobbler, dark leather, and a lingering oak-smoked finish. (01:04:40)

Lost Lantern continues to be one of the most compelling independent bottlers operating in the American whiskey space today. Whether you're chasing the delicate intricacy of a vatted blend or the rugged intensity of a peated single barrel from Nantucket, this fall collection delivers range, craftsmanship, and proof that American single malt is ready to stand alongside the world's best. Visit lostlanternwhiskey.com to shop the collection while bottles last, and if you're near a craft distillery this holiday season, stop in and show them some love.

Full Transcript

Lost Lantern American single malt Warfield Distillery Triple Eight Distillery McCarthy's single malt Clear Creek Distillery Nantucket whiskey vatted malt peated American whiskey Maris Otter malt Sauternes cask Balcones Westward Whiskey Virginia Distillery Company Cedar Ridge Westland Distilling Andalusia Whiskey craft distillery independent bottler bourbon podcast