Skip to content
Episode 487 March 18, 2026 · 46:08
487. Overholt Overload: Tasting the 10, 11, and 12-Year Cask Strength Ryes

487. Overholt Overload: Tasting the 10, 11, and 12-Year Cask Strength Ryes

Jim & Todd pour Old Overholt 10, 11, and 12 Year Cask Strength Ryes side by side — then blend all three into a mystery combo pour.

The Bourbon Road Media Player

Tasting Notes

Show Notes

Jim Shannon and Todd Ritter saddle up for an overdue promise fulfilled — a full side-by-side flight of the Old Overholt extended-age cask-strength rye series. The brand that traces its roots all the way back to 1810, when Abraham Overholt was crafting Monongahela-style rye in West Overton, Pennsylvania, has found a second life under Jim Beam's stewardship, and these limited releases are making a serious case for Old Overholt's place among premium American ryes. Jim and Todd pour all three age-stated expressions back to back, then cap the night with a blended combo pour of all three.

On the Tasting Mat:

  • Old Overholt 10 Year Cask Strength Rye: At 121 proof (60.5% ABV), this is the highest-proof pour of the evening. Released in 2023 and sourced entirely from Warehouse B in Clermont — a 12-high barrel rick with relatively consistent temperatures — this expression delivers a deep, brooding nose of dark cherry and rick-house oak with a fresh rye-spice lift. On the palate it is concentrated and powerful, leading with dark cherry and honey, resolving into a long, warming finish with white pepper and a firm chest hug. MSRP approximately $100. (00:05:03)
  • Old Overholt 11 Year Cask Strength Rye: Dropping to 107.4 proof (53.7% ABV), this late-2024 release sourced from Warehouses M, J, F, and N5 in Clermont presents a noticeably softer and cleaner nose — lighter cherry, gentle nuttiness, and subtle rick-house character. The palate opens into a surprisingly lush, candy-sweet experience with maple syrup, brown sugar, and rich crystal-sugar notes. The mouth feel is velvety and soft, and the finish, while sweet, is shorter than its siblings. MSRP approximately $100. (00:14:07)
  • Old Overholt 12 Year Cask Strength Rye: Rebounding to 117 proof (58.5% ABV) and also sourced from Warehouses M, J, F, and N5, the 12 year shifts the fruit profile toward brighter berries — raspberry, strawberry, dried cranberry — layered over a sweet cream and vanilla base. The palate is plush and mid-palate-focused, salivating and velvety, with a finish that brings together sweetness and a satisfying leather-and-white-pepper spice. Darker in the glass than its predecessors. MSRP approximately $110–$120. (00:24:39)
  • Old Overholt 10/11/12 Year Blend (Combo Pour): An equal-parts blend of all three expressions, arriving at approximately 115.3 proof. The nose shows a hint more ethanol lift than the individual bottles, with rick-house oak and a trace of the 12 Year's berry character. On the palate, the 10 Year's dark cherry asserts itself prominently, the 11 Year's maple sweetness recedes into the background, and the finish is long with a satisfying spice trail. (00:32:07)

Beyond the glass, Jim and Todd reflect on Old Overholt's remarkable 216-year history, the Beam Barreled & Boxed subscription's winding-down, and their hopes that the series continues well beyond 12 years. They also tease an upcoming pour of a 1940s Old Overholt Bottled-in-Bond with a small group of whiskey friends. As always, the show closes with a reminder that the Bourbon Roadies private Facebook group is open and welcoming — and that a new episode drops every Wednesday.

Full Transcript

Tasting Head-to-Head Bottled in Bond Bourbon Cask Strength Bottled in Bond Kentucky Pennsylvania Jim Beam Old Overholt Old Overholt cask strength Old Overholt 10 year Old Overholt 11 year Old Overholt 12 year rye whiskey Jim Beam Clermont Kentucky Monongahela rye cask strength rye age-stated rye American rye whiskey bourbon podcast The Bourbon Road rye whiskey tasting single barrel rye warehouse comparison rye whiskey flight Abraham Overholt Kentucky distillery