Skip to content
Episode 487 March 18, 2026 · 46:08
487. Overholt Overload: Tasting the 10, 11, and 12-Year Cask Strength Ryes

487. Overholt Overload: Tasting the 10, 11, and 12-Year Cask Strength Ryes

Jim & Todd go side-by-side on Old Overholt 10, 11 & 12 Year Cask Strength Ryes — then blend all three into a mystery pour.

The Bourbon Road Media Player

Reviews

Show Notes

Welcome back to The Bourbon Road, where hosts Jim Shannon and Todd Ritter sit down for a tasting they promised listeners a while back — a deep dive into the extended age Old Overholt lineup. Old Overholt holds the distinction of being the longest continuously maintained whiskey brand in the United States, tracing its roots back to 1810 when Abraham Overholt founded the distillery in West Overton, Pennsylvania. Originally celebrated as a classic Monongahela rye, the brand was acquired by Jim Beam in 1987 and given a more Kentucky-leaning mash bill with added corn, earning it a reputation as a bourbon drinker's rye. Tonight, Jim and Todd explore how that heritage translates across three different age statements, all released at cask strength.

On the Tasting Mat:

  • Old Overholt 10 Year Cask Strength Rye: Released in 2023, this expression comes in at a robust 121 proof (60.5% ABV) with an MSRP around $100. All barrels were drawn from Warehouse B in Clermont, a 12-high barrel rick with consistent temperature control. On the nose, rich dark cherry and warehouse oak lead the way, with a subtle breath of rye spice. The palate delivers concentrated dark cherry, a honey-like sweetness, and a long, warming finish with white pepper and a satisfying chest-gripping presence. (00:04:51)
  • Old Overholt 11 Year Cask Strength Rye: Released in late 2024 at 107.4 proof (53.7% ABV), also retailing around $100, this expression draws from Warehouses M, J, F, and 5 in Clermont. The nose is lighter and cleaner than the 10 year, with a nuttiness that emerges at the lower proof. On the palate, rich maple syrup, brown sugar, and candy sweetness take center stage, supported by a velvety mouthfeel. The finish, while pleasantly sweet, is shorter than the other expressions in the lineup. (00:14:07)
  • Old Overholt 12 Year Cask Strength Rye: The most recent release in the series, bottled at 117 proof (58.5% ABV) with an MSRP of approximately $110–$120, also from Warehouses M, J, F, and 5. The nose opens with vibrant berry notes — raspberry, strawberry, and jam — layered over a foundation of oak. The palate offers berries and cream, sweet vanilla icing, and dark cherry, with a lengthy, salivating finish that picks up leather and white pepper on the back end. A rich, velvety texture rounds out the experience. (00:25:09)
  • Old Overholt Blend (10, 11 & 12 Year Equal Parts): Jim and Todd combined equal portions of all three expressions into a custom blend clocking in at approximately 115.3 proof. The nose shows some ethanol presence alongside the warehouse oak and berry notes carried over from the 12 year. On the palate, the dark cherry character of the 10 year dominates, with the maple sweetness of the 11 year receding somewhat. The finish is long and complex, touching on fruit, oak, and lingering spice. (00:42:07)

From a legendary 1810 Pennsylvania farmhouse to the rick houses of Clermont, Kentucky, Old Overholt's extended age series proves that a storied mash bill still has plenty left to say. Jim and Todd raise a glass to 216 years of continuous history — and to whatever comes next in the lineup. If you want to track down any of these bottles, keep an eye on specialty retailers and ask your local bar. And if you haven't yet joined the Bourbon Roadies Facebook group or subscribed on your favorite podcast app, now's the perfect time. Until next week, we'll see you down the Bourbon Road.

Full Transcript

Old Overholt Old Overholt 10 Year Old Overholt 11 Year Old Overholt 12 Year cask strength rye rye whiskey Jim Beam Clermont Kentucky Monongahela rye bourbon drinker's rye rye whiskey tasting aged rye whiskey bourbon podcast The Bourbon Road Jim Shannon Todd Ritter whiskey comparison whiskey tasting notes American rye whiskey bourbon road podcast

The Conversation