Skip to content
Episode 486 March 11, 2026 · 46:38
486. The Return of the King: Tasting King of Kentucky Small Batches

486. The Return of the King: Tasting King of Kentucky Small Batches

Jim & Todd taste all 3 King of Kentucky Small Batch releases — Batches 1, 2 & 3 — then blend them into a fourth glass to see if the sum beats the parts.

The Bourbon Road Media Player

Reviews

Show Notes

Jim Shannon and Todd Ritter are back together at the Bourbon Road Bar, settling in with some unseasonably warm Kentucky weather and a fresh look at a brand-new release from Brown-Forman. The duo dives into the King of Kentucky Small Batch series — a rare departure from the brand's signature single-barrel format — exploring three distinct batched expressions that Brown-Forman assembled from roughly 100 barrels left over after their single-barrel selections. Released in honor of the United States' 250th anniversary, these 700ml bottlings carry ages ranging from 12 to 18 years and feature a slightly different mash bill than the typical King of Kentucky profile: 75% corn, 15% rye, and 10% malted barley. The guys also mix things up at the end by combining equal parts of all three batches into a fourth glass, putting their blending instincts to the test.

On the Tasting Mat:

  • King of Kentucky Small Batch – Batch 1: A 105-proof, 12–18 year Kentucky Straight Bourbon from Brown-Forman / Old Forester, built on a 75/15/10 corn-rye-malt mash bill. The nose opens with cherry pie crust, toasted coconut, and generous vanilla — quintessentially Old Forester in character. On the palate it turns notably dry with dark cacao, a pronounced tannic grip, dried cherry, a hint of tobacco, and a very long, clean finish that lingers well past the sip. (00:03:38)
  • King of Kentucky Small Batch – Batch 2: Stepping up to 107.5 proof with the same 12–18 year age range and mash bill, this batch shifts the aromatic profile toward darker territory — figs, dates, and dried stone fruit on the nose with less overt ethanol despite the higher proof. The palate brings more spice forward: cinnamon, pepper, and an oak-char bite alongside leathery tobacco notes. Still firmly dry, though the tannic weight is slightly less pronounced than Batch 1, replaced by a sizzling mid-palate spice. (00:12:14)
  • King of Kentucky Small Batch – Batch 3: At 110 proof, the highest of the three, Batch 3 surprises with the brightest and most lifted nose of the set — chocolate, cola, and a fresh citrus/lemon zest note that sets it apart. The palate follows through with cherry-cola richness, a faux sweetness that tricks the senses, a hint of coconut, and a warming spice tingle that coats the entire tongue. The finish is long and satisfying without tipping into excessive tannin or dryness. (00:23:29)
  • King of Kentucky Small Batch – The Blend (Equal Parts Batches 1, 2 & 3): Jim and Todd combine roughly equal measures of all three batches into a single glass, assembled approximately 25–30 minutes before tasting to allow the components to marry. The result leans into Batch 3's cola and citrus brightness while layering in the darker dried-fruit depth of Batch 2 and adding a touch more tannic structure from Batch 1. The finish is notably longer and the overall profile more balanced than any single batch alone, with notes of cola, lemon, dark cherry, chocolate, oak spice, and a whisper of coconut. (00:30:00)

Jim and Todd close out a session that proves even whiskey left on the cutting-room floor of the King of Kentucky program can deliver a serious, complex pour. Whether you track down a bottle or seek these out at a well-stocked bourbon bar, the recommendation is clear: if you can get all three in front of you at once, pour them together and see what happens.

Full Transcript

King of Kentucky King of Kentucky Small Batch Brown-Forman Old Forester Kentucky Bourbon small batch bourbon aged bourbon 12 year bourbon 18 year bourbon bourbon tasting bourbon review bourbon blending Jim Shannon Todd Ritter The Bourbon Road limited release bourbon single barrel bourbon high proof bourbon bourbon comparison bourbon podcast

The Conversation