Skip to content
Episode 486 March 11, 2026 · 46:38
486. The Return of the King: Tasting King of Kentucky Small Batches

486. The Return of the King: Tasting King of Kentucky Small Batches

Jim & Todd taste all 3 King of Kentucky Small Batches (105, 107.5 & 110 proof) side by side — then blend them to crown a champion.

The Bourbon Road Media Player

Tasting Notes

Show Notes

Jim Shannon and Todd Ritter are back together at the Bourbon Road Bar for a rare and exciting tasting: the brand-new small batch releases from King of Kentucky, Brown-Forman's ultra-premium Old Forester expression. These three batches mark a departure from the label's signature single-barrel format — instead, Brown-Forman batched approximately 100 remaining barrels, some of which didn't make the cut for single-barrel release due to low yields, into three distinct expressions differentiated by proof. Aged anywhere from 12 to 18 years and built on a slightly different mash bill than the standard King of Kentucky (75% corn, 15% rye, 10% malted barley), these 700mL bottles carry an MSRP of $299 each and were released in honor of the 250th anniversary of the United States. A special thanks to friend of the show John Peets (aka Top Dog) for sharing samples of all three batches — and for the inspired suggestion to blend them.

On the Tasting Mat:

  • King of Kentucky Small Batch – Batch 1 (105 proof): The opening pour from Brown-Forman's limited small batch series. Aged 12–18 years on a 75/15/10 corn-rye-malt mash bill, this 105-proof expression opens with a gorgeous Old Forester nose — cherry pie crust, toasted coconut, rich vanilla, and a hint of dark chocolate. The palate is notably dry with dark cacao, firm tannins, and dried cherry fruit. The finish is lengthy and oak-driven, coating the back of the palate with tobacco and spice. Extremely viscous with a sheet-of-oil texture in the glass. (00:03:59)
  • King of Kentucky Small Batch – Batch 2 (107.5 proof): The middle expression in the trio steps up 2.5 proof points and reveals a notably darker nose — dried figs, dates, and deep stone fruit replace the brighter top notes of Batch 1. Less ethanol volatility on the nose despite the higher proof. The palate brings more spice forward with cinnamon, black pepper, leathery tobacco, and oak char. Tannins are present but slightly less dominant than Batch 1, with the dry, long finish continuing the theme of the series. Beautifully viscous. (00:12:14)
  • King of Kentucky Small Batch – Batch 3 (110 proof): The highest-proof entry in the trio surprises with a brighter, more expressive character. The nose carries rich chocolate, a distinctive cola note, and a fresh citrus lift reminiscent of lemon in a diet cola. On the palate, a faux sweetness emerges — cherry cola and dark chocolate with a zesty citrus zing — creating an impression of richness without overt sugar. The finish delivers a full-tongue spicy tingle that lingers, with coconut peeking through on the back end. The most layered and front-to-back expressive of the three batches. (00:23:20)
  • King of Kentucky Small Batch – The Blend (equal parts Batches 1, 2 & 3, ~107.5 proof): A house blend created by Jim and Todd using approximately equal pours of all three batches, assembled roughly 25–30 minutes before tasting to allow the components to marry. The nose is led by the cola brightness of Batch 3 with added depth. The palate unites the dark fruit of Batch 2, the spice and tingle of Batch 3, and a moderate tannic structure from Batch 1, producing a more balanced and integrated experience. Coconut, lemon, dark cherry, cola, and oak spice all register. The finish is notably longer than any single batch. (00:29:54)

Jim and Todd close out a memorable session by working through a four-way ranked comparison — including the impromptu blend — before finishing their glasses of the winning batch neat. Whether you track these down at a great bourbon bar, befriend someone who scored a bottle, or catch them at retail for $299, the King of Kentucky Small Batches are a fascinating look at what Brown-Forman does with its deepest, oldest stocks. Cheers to John Peets for making this full comparison possible.

Full Transcript

Unknown Tasting Bourbon Small Batch Kentucky Brown-Forman Old Forester King of Kentucky King of Kentucky Small Batch Old Forester Brown-Forman bourbon tasting small batch bourbon aged bourbon 18 year bourbon Kentucky bourbon premium bourbon bourbon comparison bourbon blend high proof bourbon bourbon review Bourbon Road podcast Jim Shannon Todd Ritter limited release bourbon wheated bourbon whiskey tasting