Skip to content
Episode 518 October 21, 2026 · 51:33
518. Heirloom Grains & Hazardous Proof: A Craft Rye Deep Dive

518. Heirloom Grains & Hazardous Proof: A Craft Rye Deep Dive

All rye, all night: Lock & Co. Aspen Age, Stolen Wolf Rosin Rye, NY Distilling Jaywalk Heirloom, and Whiskey Thief's 145-proof Hazardous Rye.

The Bourbon Road Media Player

Reviews

Show Notes

Welcome back, Roadies! Jim Shannon and Todd are back behind the bar for another fun-filled evening at the Bourbon Road bar, and this week they've gone all-in on rye whiskey. Fresh off the excitement of Bourbon on the Banks in Frankfort, Kentucky — including a wildly successful Bourbon Road meetup at the Frankfurt Bourbon Society Corner Rick House — the guys settle in for a four-bottle flight of craft ryes spanning a remarkable proof range of 90 to 145. From historic grain varieties to concentrated barrel experiments, this lineup proves that rye whiskey is anything but one-dimensional.

On the Tasting Mat:

  • Lock & Co. Distilling Aspen Age Rye (Denver, CO): A 90-proof, 95/5 rye mash bill distilled in Denver, Colorado and aged over two years in new 30-gallon oak barrels from the Barrel Mill in Minnesota, then finished for eight months with hand-cut charred Aspen wood disks. The nose is fresh, minty, and inviting — like standing at the Colorado tree line — with a bright, crisp palate and just enough oak bite to confirm its age. Light, sessionable, and wonderfully refreshing. (00:09:28)
  • Stolen Wolf Distillery Rosin Rye (Lititz, PA): A 106.5-proof, approximately 31-month single-barrel expression built around the historically significant Rosen rye grain — developed in the mid-1910s by Joseph A. Rosen, nearly lost to extinction, and revived starting in 2015 from a five-ounce USDA seed bank sample. Grown locally by the Klein family farm in Lancaster County, Pennsylvania, and first distilled in 2019 by the late master distiller Dick Stoll. The nose is subdued and earthy, while the palate is dry, tannic, and laced with baking spice — a distinctly different character from modern rye expressions. (00:18:17)
  • New York Distilling Company Jaywalk Heirloom Rye (New York): A 116-proof, single-barrel expression aged seven to nine years and built from a mash bill of 75% Horton rye, 13% New York corn, and 12% malted barley. The Horton rye variety dates to the 17th century and was revived from just 10 surviving seeds through a collaboration with Cornell University, with the grain grown in the Finger Lakes region. The nose is subdued with hints of fruit, while the palate reveals a rich, bready, nutty character — black walnut, green walnut, stone fruit, and a complexity that reflects its age. Retails around $102. (00:26:42)
  • Whiskey Thief Distilling Company Hazardous Rye (Frankfort, KY): A cask-strength, straight-from-the-barrel release bottled at a staggering 145 proof (72.5% ABV), sourced from barrels that were aged out after being repeatedly sampled via whiskey thief at the distillery, then returned to the rick house to concentrate further. A 95/5 rye mash bill aged approximately seven years. The color is the darkest of the flight; the nose is rich with dark fruit and ethanol intensity, while the palate is warming, syrupy, candy-like, and packed with barrel char. A bottle generously provided by David Sandlin of House of Commons in Frankfort. Retails around $199.99. (00:33:36)

Todd and Jim round out the evening with a retrospective ranking and a heartfelt recap of the Bourbon on the Banks weekend, including the Bourbon Road meetup that drew dozens of Roadies, giveaways, and pours from over 50 bottles. If you haven't yet explored the brand-new TheBourbanRoad.com, now is the time — over 1,320 whiskey reviews, all 500-plus episodes, searchable tasting notes with embedded audio clips, and the all-new Roadie Bar community await you.

Full Transcript

Lock and Co Distilling Aspen Age Rye Stolen Wolf Distillery Rosin Rye Rosen rye New York Distilling Company Jaywalk Heirloom Rye Horton rye Whiskey Thief Distilling Hazardous Rye craft rye whiskey cask strength rye Empire Rye heirloom grain whiskey Bourbon on the Banks Frankfurt Bourbon Society House of Commons Frankfort David Sandlin rye whiskey review Kentucky bourbon festival

The Conversation