Skip to content
Episode 104 October 21, 2020 · 38:43
104. All About Extra Aged Bourbons

104. All About Extra Aged Bourbons

Jim & Mike go extra-aged, tasting Elijah Craig 18 Year and Knob Creek 15 Year side by side to explore what oak does over the long haul.

The Bourbon Road Media Player

Tasting Notes

Show Notes

Jim Shannon and Mike Hyatt are back in Studio 2A at Jeff the Bin Farm, the autumn leaves blazing outside the windows as they settle in for a deep dive into extra-aged Kentucky bourbon. This week the duo pulls two well-aged bottles off Mike's shelf to explore what extended time in oak actually does to a whiskey — and whether more years always means a better drink.

On the Tasting Mat:

  • Elijah Craig 18 Year Old: Bottled at 90 proof from Heaven Hill's traditional mashbill of 78% corn, 12% malted barley, and 10% rye, this expression is available at the distillery gift shop and select retailers for around $150 MSRP. On the nose it delivers a beautiful and surprising burst of orange, butter, caramel, and chocolate orange sweetness. The palate is rich with fruit compote notes — apples, cherries, and peaches — alongside honey cough drop sweetness, a subtle tannic bitterness from the oak, and a lingering warmth that punches well above its modest proof. The finish is medium in length. (00:04:20)
  • Knob Creek 15 Year Old (2020 Special Release): Released in June 2020 and bottled at 100 proof from Jim Beam's mashbill of 75% corn, 13% rye, and 12% malted barley, this limited edition expression retails for around $100. The nose leads with darker, more focused fruit — raisins and plums — layered with pronounced oak and leather. The palate is bold and spice-forward, drawing heat from both the rye content and the barrel, with notes of caramel, brown sugar, and a surprising minty freshness on the entry. The oak presence is powerful but opens up and softens with time in the glass, revealing a longer, more inviting finish that keeps calling for another sip. (00:17:37)

Whether you're drawn to the bright, fruit-forward elegance of extended Heaven Hill aging or the bold, oak-driven authority of a high-proof Beam expression, this episode is a masterclass in what Kentucky's climate and cooperage can coax out of a barrel over the long haul. Jim and Mike also tease the imminent release of their very first distillery barrel pick — available exclusively to members of the Bourbon Roadies Facebook group — and break down how bourbon age ranges shape the character of everything from your everyday pour to the rarest shelf finds.

Full Transcript

Bourbon Road Narrator Mike Hyatt Tasting Bourbon Kentucky Heaven Hill Jim Beam Elijah Craig 18 Year Knob Creek 15 Year Heaven Hill Jim Beam extra aged bourbon Kentucky bourbon bourbon age barrel aging oak influence 2020 special release bourbon tasting bourbon podcast The Bourbon Road bourbon fall sipping high proof bourbon mashbill rick house bourbon pick Bourbon Roadies aged whiskey