Skip to content
Episode 344 May 3, 2023 · 54:06
344, Penelope, Wolcott and Weller

344, Penelope, Wolcott and Weller

Jim & Brian sip Wolcott 90, Penelope Four Grain, and Weller Special Reserve while previewing Derby week and the Tennessee Whiskey Trail Experience.

The Bourbon Road Media Player

Tasting Notes

Show Notes

Jim Shannon and Brian Hyatt settle in for a relaxed reset episode, swapping out guests for good conversation and a handful of bottles that deserve more attention on the shelf. From a sleeper release out of the Barton 1792 distillery to an approachable four-grain newcomer and a classic weated bourbon that never gets old, this is the kind of episode that reminds you why you fell in love with bourbon in the first place. Pour yourself something and pull up a chair.

On the Tasting Mat:

  • Wolcott Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey (90 Proof): Distilled at the Barton 1792 Distillery in Bardstown, Kentucky, this rye-forward bourbon carries a 51% corn mash bill and checks in at 90 proof. The nose opens with vanilla and light oak alongside faint cherry and a hint of pear from the barley. On the palate it delivers classic vanilla and caramel with a cherry-driven mid-palate and a warm, slightly drying pepper finish. A solid, well-rounded everyday pour at around $30. (00:03:56)
  • Penelope Four Grain Straight Bourbon Whiskey (80 Proof): An 80-proof four-grain bourbon retailing around $37, the Penelope pours a very pale straw color. The nose is soft and approachable with sweet, apple-forward fruit notes and zero alcohol heat. The palate leans sweet and slightly creamy with vanilla and a gentle citrus character the label describes as tangerine. The finish is pleasant but relatively short and thin. A good introductory bottle for fans of lighter, sweeter bourbon styles. (00:08:41)
  • Weller Special Reserve (90 Proof): The entry-level expression of the Weller line, this wheated bourbon from Buffalo Trace Distillery clocks in at 90 proof. The nose is soft, sweet, and understated — honey, vanilla, and caramel with barely a whisper of oak and zero ethanol burn. The palate follows suit with honey, a touch of fruit, and a gentle floral character that is easier to find on the sip than on the nose. The finish warms gradually with a comforting oaky depth and mild heat. A classic, approachable wheater that serves as a reliable compass reset. (00:36:27)

Beyond the bottles, Jim and Brian preview a packed calendar — the Kentucky Derby, the Tennessee Whiskey Trail Experience in Nashville (May 18–21), Bourbon on the Banks in Frankfort (October 6–7), and the Kentucky Bourbon Festival — while welcoming new sponsor Blanton's Bourbon Shop. Tune in next week for a Derby Day sit-down with the Uncle Nearest team.

Full Transcript

Brian Hyatt Tasting Bourbon Wheated Tennessee Whiskey Kentucky Tennessee Buffalo Trace Distillery Buffalo Trace Wolcott bourbon Penelope Four Grain Weller Special Reserve Barton 1792 distillery Buffalo Trace wheated bourbon four grain bourbon rye bourbon Kentucky bourbon bourbon podcast The Bourbon Road Jim Shannon Brian Hyatt Blanton's Bourbon Shop Uncle Nearest Tennessee Whiskey Trail Bourbon on the Banks Kentucky Derby affordable bourbon bourbon tasting