Skip to content
Episode 344 May 3, 2023 · 54:06
344, Penelope, Wolcott and Weller

344, Penelope, Wolcott and Weller

Jim Shannon & Brian Hyatt taste Wolcott 90, Penelope Four Grain, and Weller Special Reserve — three shelf-friendly bottles worth knowing.

The Bourbon Road Media Player

Reviews

Show Notes

Jim Shannon and co-host Brian Hyatt settle in for a relaxed, compass-resetting episode of The Bourbon Road — no guests, just two friends pouring a few bottles that have been catching their eye on the shelf. Fresh off a whirlwind stretch of Southern road trips, distillery visits, and music artist interviews, the guys take a breath and focus on what it's all about: finding good bourbon at a fair price and sharing it with the people you enjoy. Along the way they preview some big upcoming episodes — Uncle Nearest, Hemingway Rye, Buzzard's Roost, Hard Truth, and more — and talk about the exciting slate of events on the bourbon calendar, from the Kentucky Derby to the Tennessee Whiskey Trail Experience and Bourbon on the Banks in Frankfort.

On the Tasting Mat:

  • Wolcott Straight Bourbon Whiskey (90 Proof): Distilled at the Barton 1792 Distillery in Bardstown, Kentucky (a Buffalo Trace / Sazerac operation), this 51% corn, high-rye expression retails around $30. The nose opens with classic vanilla and a whisper of oak, with soft cherry and a faint nuttiness that takes some coaxing. The palate delivers vanilla, caramel, and cherry in a medium-bodied, center-of-the-road style. The finish has a gentle drying quality and a warm black pepper kick — signature 1792 DNA. A quietly solid bottle that rewards the patient shopper willing to look past flashier labels. (00:04:05)
  • Penelope Four Grain Straight Bourbon Whiskey (80 Proof): A non-distiller-produced four-grain bourbon bottled around $37, the Penelope Four Grain pours a notably light straw color. The nose is soft and approachable with sweet, lightly fruity apple notes and zero ethanol aggression. On the palate it reads sweet and creamy with clear vanilla influence and a hint of tangerine citrus that echoes the bottle's own tasting descriptors. The finish is relatively brief and thin but pleasant — a crowd-friendly sipper that prioritizes ease and sweetness over complexity. (00:03:20)
  • Weller Special Reserve (90 Proof / Green Label): The entry point of the Buffalo Trace Antique Collection's wheated lineup, the Special Reserve is a 90-proof wheated bourbon that the guys revisit as a deliberate palate reset. The nose is gentle and inviting — vanilla, caramel, and a soft floral lift with no heat to speak of. The palate opens sweet and honey-forward with a creamy, slightly thin texture and quiet fruit underneath. The finish transitions into a warm, oaky dry-down that provides a satisfying counterpoint to the soft entry. A classic, uncomplicated pour that earns its reputation through consistency and approachability rather than boldness. (00:28:01)

The crew wraps up with a look ahead at a packed event season — the Kentucky Derby, the Tennessee Whiskey Trail Experience (May 18–21 in Nashville), the Kentucky Bourbon Festival, and Bourbon on the Banks (October 6–7 in Frankfort, featuring a barrel pick from Lawrenceburg Bourbon Company). Whether you're hunting a sleeper bottle at $30 or simply craving a reset sip of something familiar, this episode is a friendly reminder that great bourbon doesn't have to break the bank — and that the best pour is often the one shared with good company.

Full Transcript

Wolcott bourbon Penelope Four Grain Weller Special Reserve Barton 1792 Distillery Buffalo Trace wheated bourbon four grain bourbon affordable bourbon Kentucky Derby bourbon Bourbon on the Banks Tennessee Whiskey Trail Experience Lawrenceburg Bourbon Company Uncle Nearest Hemingway Rye Buzzard's Roost Hard Truth Distillery rye bourbon barrel pick bourbon tasting The Bourbon Road podcast

The Conversation