Skip to content
Episode 348 May 31, 2023 · 50:23
348. Single Barrel Select Showdown

348. Single Barrel Select Showdown

Jim & Brian taste three store-pick single barrels back-to-back: Russell's Reserve Camp Nelson, Maker's Mark Fireside Spice, and Knob Creek 120 Proof.

The Bourbon Road Media Player

Tasting Notes

Show Notes

Jim Shannon and Brian Hyatt settle into Brian's back patio on a breezy late-May afternoon — smoker going, kids splashing in the pool behind them — for a deep dive into the booming world of single-barrel selections. The guys reflect on just how dramatically the barrel-pick wall at big-box retailers has grown, then crack open three store picks pulled straight from the shelves of Total Wine to see what all the fuss is about.

On the Tasting Mat:

  • Russell's Reserve Single Barrel Select (Camp Nelson A, Floor 4): Distilled April 2013, dumped January 12, 2023 — just shy of 10 years old — at 110 proof. A high-rye Wild Turkey mashbill delivers unmistakable house character: English toffee, aromatic citrus, dark plum, and fig on the nose, with a rich, viscous palate of dried fruit and a long, spicy finish that lingers with notes of cinnamon, black pepper, and a whisper of Good & Plenty licorice. A Total Wine pick retailing at $97.99. (00:04:28)
  • Maker's Mark Private Selection "Fireside Spice": Dumped July 2022 at 108.4 proof. This wheated bourbon was finished on 10 staves — two Baked American Pure, four Roasted French Moëndeon, and four Toasted French Spice — delivering an inviting nose of maple syrup and warm caramel with a gentle ethanol sizzle. The palate is syrupy and silky-smooth, offering brown sugar, almond, a hint of sweet chewing-tobacco leaf, and a pleasant medium-length finish. A Total Wine pick at $85.99. (00:21:24)
  • Knob Creek Single Barrel Select 120 Proof: Barreled October 1, 2013 and selected January 2023 — approximately nine and a half years old. At 120 proof this Jim Beam mashbill bourbon presents a bold nose of burnt marshmallow, crème brûlée, atomic fireball cinnamon, and rich leather. Surprisingly approachable on the palate for its proof, it delivers charred oak, burnt sugar, and a pleasantly drying tannic finish with medium-to-long persistence. A Total Wine pick at $62.99. (00:31:57)

Jim and Brian wrap up with a conversation about the art of barrel picking, their favorite Louisville spots to find single barrels — including Westport Whiskey & Wine — and a preview of the bourbon picks they're planning for their booth at Bourbon on the Banks in Frankfort, Kentucky on October 6th and 7th. Whether you're hunting value or chasing age statements, this episode is a practical guide to navigating the ever-expanding world of retail single-barrel selections.

Full Transcript

Unknown Brian Hyatt Tasting Bourbon Wheated Single Barrel Kentucky Jim Beam Wild Turkey Russell's Reserve Wild Turkey Camp Nelson single barrel barrel pick Maker's Mark Fireside Spice wheated bourbon Knob Creek 120 proof Total Wine bourbon tasting high rye mashbill barrel select Westport Whiskey and Wine bourbon review retail bourbon single barrel selection Kentucky bourbon Bourbon Road podcast