Skip to content
Episode 348 May 31, 2023 · 50:23
348. Single Barrel Select Showdown

348. Single Barrel Select Showdown

Jim & Brian taste three Total Wine barrel picks: Russell's Reserve Camp Nelson, Maker's Mark Fireside Spice, and Knob Creek 120 proof — live from Brian's back porch.

The Bourbon Road Media Player

Reviews

Show Notes

Jim Shannon and Brian Hyatt settle into Brian's back patio on a breezy early-summer afternoon, smoker going and kids splashing in the pool behind them, for a deep dive into the world of retail single-barrel selections. The episode explores how the barrel-pick program has exploded at big-box liquor stores — from a handful of bottles on an end-cap to entire walls of store-exclusive picks — and what that means for the bourbon consumer. Three well-known brands, all selected by Total Wine, make it onto the tasting mat, covering a range of mashbills, proofs, ages, and price points.

On the Tasting Mat:

  • Russell's Reserve Single Barrel Select (Camp Nelson A, Floor 4, 110 proof): Distilled April 2013, dumped January 12, 2023 — just shy of ten years old. This Wild Turkey camp Nelson warehouse pick opens with English toffee, aromatic citrus, and a floral fruitiness on the nose. The palate delivers a wash of dark fruit — fig, plum, and raisin jam — with a backbone of spice and a long, lingering finish that evolves through cinnamon, black pepper, and a touch of Good & Plenty licorice. Priced at $97.99. (00:04:28)
  • Maker's Mark Private Selection "Fireside Spice" (108.4 proof): A Total Wine barrel finished with 10 staves — two Baked American Pure, four Roasted French Mondéon, and four Toasted French Spice — and dumped July 2022. The nose is inviting and maple-forward with a light ethanol warmth. On the palate it is notably silky and syrupy, with caramel, cinnamon, and a sweet chewing-tobacco note on the mid-palate. The finish is medium in length, pleasant, and slightly nutty. Priced at $85.99. (00:19:24)
  • Knob Creek Single Barrel Select (120 proof): Barreled October 1, 2013 and selected January 2023, making it approximately nine and a half years old. The nose leads with burnt marshmallow, crème brûlée, atomic fireball cinnamon, and leather — bold and rick-house-forward without an aggressive alcohol punch. The palate is thick and oak-driven with dried fruit and a slightly drying tannic quality from the well-aged wood. The finish is medium-to-long and satisfying. Priced at $62.99. (00:30:37)

Jim and Brian close out the afternoon talking about their favorite barrel-pick retailers in Louisville, the immersive experience of picking barrels at Wild Turkey with Eddie Russell, and a preview of the Bourbon Road's own upcoming barrel selections for Bourbon on the Banks (October 6–7, Frankfort, KY) in partnership with Lawrenceburg Bourbon Company. Whether you are a seasoned single-barrel hunter or just starting to explore store picks, this episode is a practical and enjoyable guide to what is on the shelf right now.

Full Transcript

Russell's Reserve Wild Turkey Camp Nelson single barrel barrel pick Maker's Mark Fireside Spice French oak staves Knob Creek 120 proof Total Wine store pick bourbon tasting weeded bourbon high rye bourbon Bourbon on the Banks Lawrenceburg Bourbon Company barrel select Kentucky bourbon bourbon trail

The Conversation