Skip to content
Episode 441 April 23, 2025 · 42:04
441. Winner Winner Chicken Dinner

441. Winner Winner Chicken Dinner

Jim & Todd pour four: Gypsy Double Barrel, Liberty Pole Old Monongahela Rye, 15 Stars Three Ports, and Jacob's Pardon 18yr 142.7-proof American whiskey.

The Bourbon Road Media Player

Tasting Notes

Show Notes

Jim Shannon and Todd Ritter are back at the Corner Rick House, arriving early ahead of a Frankfurt Bourbon Society event with four bottles lined up and ready to go. The lineup spans the full spectrum of American whiskey — a double-barreled bourbon from a celebrity-backed brand, a pot-distilled Old Monongahela-style rye out of Pennsylvania, an aged Kentucky straight bourbon with a triple port-cask finish, and a jaw-dropping 18-year high-proof American whiskey with a Prohibition-era backstory. Pull up a chair, grab your favorite pour, and dig in.

On the Tasting Mat:

  • Gypsy Double Barrel Bourbon: A 86-proof double-barreled Kentucky straight bourbon from the brand backed by country singer Eric Church. Blended from a minimum of four-year-old whiskey and finished in a second new American oak barrel. The nose opens with vanilla, caramel, and a sugary sweetness, while the palate delivers a touch more spice and body than the proof suggests, with an approachable, smooth finish. Retails around $44.99. (00:02:47)
  • Liberty Pole Spirits Old Monongahela Full Proof Rye Whiskey: A pot-distilled rye out of Washington, Pennsylvania, carrying a mash bill of 74% rye, 13% wheat, and 13% malted barley. The youngest barrel in the blend is at least three and a half years old, bottled at 108 proof. The nose leads with cereal grain and a spiced gumdrop quality, while the palate is bread-forward, mouth-coating, and lingers with a zippy rye spice and subtle mint on the finish. Ordered directly from the distillery for around $67. (00:09:03)
  • 15 Stars Fine Aged Spirits Three Ports: A Kentucky straight bourbon finished across three separate port casks — tawny, white, and ruby — blending 15-year-old and 9-year-old bourbon at 105 proof. Deep mahogany in color, the nose offers blueberry, concord grape, and a hint of banana from the base bourbon. The palate is rich, layered, and savory, with berry compote, dark fruit, and a well-integrated oak structure. Retails around $149. (00:21:32)
  • Jacob's Pardon 18 Year Small Batch American Whiskey: An 18-year-old American whiskey bottled at a staggering 142.7 proof, inspired by the Prohibition-era story of brothers Jacob and Abner Taub, who were ultimately pardoned by President Franklin D. Roosevelt. The nose delivers burnt sugar, sweet bread, and cotton candy with a smoky undertone. On the palate it is intensely sweet, warming, and buttery with notable complexity for the category, gaining depth from extended aging. Retails around $195. (00:28:25)

Four bottles, four distinct personalities — from an easy-drinking celebrity double-barrel to a historic-style Pennsylvania rye, a triple-port finished aged blend, and a Prohibition-era hazmat-proof American whiskey. Jim and Todd wrap with a full ranking and plenty of spirited debate about proof, craft distilling's maturation, regional whiskey styles, and what's coming up at Bourbon on the Banks. Roadies, this one covers a lot of ground.

Full Transcript

Tasting Bourbon Rye Cask Strength Finished Small Batch Kentucky Pennsylvania Gypsy Double Barrel Bourbon Eric Church bourbon Liberty Pole Spirits Old Monongahela rye Pennsylvania rye whiskey 15 Stars Fine Aged Spirits three ports bourbon port cask finish Jacob's Pardon American whiskey hazmat proof whiskey Frankfurt Bourbon Society Bourbon on the Banks craft distillery double barrel bourbon high proof bourbon rye whiskey review Kentucky straight bourbon aged whiskey Bourbon Road podcast