Skip to content
Episode 441 April 23, 2025 · 42:04
441. Winner Winner Chicken Dinner

441. Winner Winner Chicken Dinner

Jim & Todd taste Gypsy Double Barrel, Liberty Pole Old Monongahela Rye, 15 Stars Three Ports, and Jacob's Pardon 18-Year at 142.7 proof.

The Bourbon Road Media Player

Reviews

Show Notes

Jim Shannon and Todd Ritter are back at the Corner Rickhouse in Frankfort, Kentucky, getting set up early before a Frankfurt Bourbon Society event. With four bottles lined up and good company on the way, the guys settle in for a wide-ranging tasting that spans double-barreled bourbon, a historic Monongahela-style rye, a triple port-cask-finished Kentucky straight bourbon, and a rare ultra-high-proof American whiskey. Along the way they swap stories about Eric Church, Billy Strings, Tyler Childers, and the latest news from Bourbon on the Banks Festival — including word that only about 350 tickets remain for the October 4th event in Frankfort.

On the Tasting Mat:

  • Gypsy Double Barrel Bourbon: A blend of a minimum four-year-old Kentucky bourbon re-barreled into new American oak, bottled at 86 proof and retailing around $44.99. The nose opens with inviting vanilla, caramel, and a sugary sweetness the guys attribute to the second barrel. On the palate it delivers gentle spice alongside the sweetness, with an accessible, approachable profile that makes it an ideal introduction to double-barreled expressions. (00:02:47)
  • Liberty Pole Spirits Old Monongahela Full-Proof Rye Whiskey: A pot-distilled rye from Washington, Pennsylvania, built on a mash bill of 74% rye, 13% wheat, and 13% malted barley, with the youngest barrel in the blend aged at least 3.5 years. Bottled at 108 proof and retailing around $67, this expression leads with a grain-forward, slightly bread-y nose before revealing spice drop, rye muffin, fresh mint, and a rich, mouth-coating, buttery texture on the palate. A compelling modern revival of the historic Monongahela rye style. (00:09:03)
  • 15 Stars Fine Aged Spirits Three Ports: A Kentucky straight bourbon whiskey triple-cask finished in tawny, white, and ruby port barrels, blending 15-year-old and nine-year-old bourbon and bottled at 105 proof, retailing around $149. The color runs a deep, chocolatey red. The nose layers blueberry, Concord grape, and a whisper of banana from the base bourbon, while the palate rewards with blackberry compote, raspberry, rich oak, and a savory, almost meaty depth. A craft from Indiana farm family brand 15 Stars, sourced and finished in partnership with Bardstown Bourbon Company. (00:21:20)
  • Jacob's Pardon 18 Year Small Batch American Whiskey: An 18-year-old American whiskey bottled at a formidable 142.7 proof, retailing around $195. Inspired by the true story of brothers Jacob and Abner Taub, who were pardoned by President Franklin D. Roosevelt after being jailed for violating the Volstead Act during Prohibition, this whiskey is carried forward by their great-nephews. The nose offers burnt sugar, sweet bread, and warming aromatics, while the palate delivers cotton candy, sweet smoke, and a lush buttery texture, with an age-driven complexity uncommon in the American whiskey category. (00:28:25)

The guys wrap up with a ranking of all four bottles, good-natured math at high proof, and anticipation for the evening ahead — Stanton Holder is driving up from Florida, cigars almost certainly in tow, ready to join the Frankfurt Bourbon Society gathering. Until next time, see you down the Bourbon Road.

Full Transcript

Gypsy Double Barrel Bourbon Eric Church whiskey Liberty Pole Spirits Old Monongahela Rye Monongahela rye 15 Stars bourbon 15 Stars Three Ports port cask finished bourbon Jacob's Pardon American whiskey hazmat proof whiskey Bardstown Bourbon Company Frankfurt Bourbon Society Bourbon on the Banks Festival pot distilled rye double barrel bourbon Kentucky straight bourbon rye whiskey high proof bourbon craft distillery

The Conversation