Skip to content
Episode 317 November 2, 2022 · 42:00
317. Calumet Farm 14, 15 and 16 Year Side-By-Side

317. Calumet Farm 14, 15 and 16 Year Side-By-Side

Jim & Mike taste through Calumet Farm 8, 14, 15 & 16-Year bourbons, tracing how a Barton-sourced barrel evolves — and when it peaks.

The Bourbon Road Media Player

Reviews

Show Notes

Welcome back to The Bourbon Road! Jim Shannon and Mike Hyatt settle in for a focused tasting session that traces the arc of barrel aging across three vintage expressions from Calumet Farm. Sourced from what is widely believed to be the Barton 1792 Distillery in Bardstown, Kentucky, and bottled by Western Spirits out of Bowling Green, these whiskeys share the same mash bill — 74% corn, 18% rye, and 8% malted barley — but diverge meaningfully as the years in the barrel accumulate. Before diving in, the guys take a quick detour through science class, tackling the question of why whiskey and water don't separate in the bottle, and how chill filtration relates to those mysterious white flecks that sometimes appear in a pour.

On the Tasting Mat:

  • Calumet Farm 14-Year Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey: Bottled at 96.2 proof, this expression opens with rich butterscotch on the nose alongside dark fruit and a notable peppery backbone. The palate delivers deep caramel and vanilla with a drying, mildly tannic oak presence. Sourced from barrels believed to originate at the Barton 1792 Distillery, it presents classic Kentucky bourbon character with a nutty, Dr. Pepper-and-peanuts quality that both hosts associate with the Barton house style. (00:13:50)
  • Calumet Farm 15-Year Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey: Proofed up to 105, this bottling builds on the 14-year foundation with a more pronounced oak structure and a bolder, freshly cracked pepper spice. The extra year and higher proof bring greater intensity to the mid-palate caramel and dark fruit notes, while the finish grows longer and drier. The nutty, Dr. Pepper character remains a throughline. Available at select Kroger locations for approximately $129. (00:22:57)
  • Calumet Farm 16-Year Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey: At 106 proof, this expression pushes the oak to the forefront. The nose carries more bite and tannic sharpness than its younger siblings, and on the palate the sweetness has receded considerably, leaving behind a pronounced drying, bitter oak presence. Traces of Dr. Pepper and peanuts persist, though the fruit notes from earlier expressions have largely faded. A bottle for devoted fans of heavily aged, assertively oaky Kentucky bourbon. (00:27:12)
  • Calumet Farm 8-Year "The Pedigree" Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey: A small-batch blend of 50 barrels, bottled at 90 proof. This entry-level expression from the Calumet lineup delivers a noticeably sweeter, fruitier profile — red fruit up front, white pepper mid-palate, and the familiar nuttiness on the finish. The oak is present but well-integrated at this age, and the overall character is approachable and sessionable. Picked up on sale at Kroger for around $41. (00:31:05)

The guys close out the episode reflecting on how Calumet Farm's releases capture something essential about Kentucky bourbon's relationship with time and wood. Whether you prefer the sweet accessibility of the 8-year, the bold balance of the 15-year, or the full oak expression of the 16-year, the whole lineup tells a coherent story about what happens inside a white oak barrel over the course of a Kentucky decade and a half. As always, grab a glass, pour something you love, and we'll see you down the Bourbon Road.

Full Transcript

Calumet Farm Calumet Farm 14 year Calumet Farm 15 year Calumet Farm 16 year Calumet Farm 8 year Western Spirits Barton 1792 Distillery Bardstown Kentucky aged bourbon Kentucky straight bourbon barrel aging over-oaked bourbon high rye bourbon sourced bourbon bourbon tasting bourbon comparison chill filtration bourbon proof Jim Shannon Mike Hyatt

The Conversation