Skip to content
Episode 317 November 2, 2022 · 42:00
317. Calumet Farm 14, 15 and 16 Year Side-By-Side

317. Calumet Farm 14, 15 and 16 Year Side-By-Side

Jim & Mike taste through Calumet Farm 14, 15, 16 & 8-year bourbons to trace the full arc of barrel aging from Western Spirits.

The Bourbon Road Media Player

Tasting Notes

Show Notes

Jim Shannon and Mike Hyatt saddle up for a deep dive into the Calumet Farm aged whiskey lineup, walking listeners through the maturation arc of a single distillery's barrels as they progress from 14 to 16 years in the barrel. Sourced from what both hosts believe to be the Barton 1792 distillery in Bardstown and bottled by Western Spirits out of Bowling Green, Kentucky, the Calumet Farm series has earned a reputation as one of the more distinguished aged expressions on the shelf. Jim and Mike pour through each vintage in sequence, then circle back to the younger eight-year entry to round out the full picture of how time in Kentucky's climate shapes a whiskey.

On the Tasting Mat:

  • Calumet Farm 14-Year Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey: Bottled at 96.2 proof with a mash bill of 74% corn, 18% rye, and 8% malted barley, this expression opens with rich butterscotch on the nose alongside deep caramel and a hint of dark fruit. The palate carries a notable drying quality with pepper and oak well-integrated, and the finish leans dry with a subtle nutty character both hosts associate with Barton-sourced juice. (00:20:58)
  • Calumet Farm 15-Year Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey: Stepped up to 105 proof from the same mash bill, the 15-year shows a more pronounced spice profile — freshly cracked black pepper on a Caesar salad, as Mike puts it — alongside that signature Dr. Pepper and peanut character. The oak has deepened compared to the 14-year, and the higher proof gives the mid-palate more presence, with dark caramel and a warming finish that lingers with dry, woodsy tannins. (00:25:58)
  • Calumet Farm 16-Year Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey: At 106 proof and another year in the barrel, this expression pushes the oak note firmly to the forefront. The nose carries more bite and the palate leads with significant wood tannins and a strong drying finish. A ghost of syrupy Dr. Pepper sweetness and peanut character still linger for Mike, though the fruit notes that defined the earlier expressions have largely faded. Built for fans of bold, heavily aged bourbons. (00:27:07)
  • Calumet Farm 8-Year "The Pedigree" Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey: A 50-barrel small batch bottled at 90 proof from the same 74/18/8 mash bill, this entry-level expression reintroduces brighter fruit — leaning toward red fruit rather than the dark fruit of the aged lineup — alongside fresh pepper and the familiar nutty backbone. The oak is present but not dominant, and the overall profile is more accessible and sessionable than its older siblings. Approachable enough to share a whole bottle by the fire, Jim suggests. (00:31:05)

Jim and Mike wrap the tasting with some reflection on the arc of barrel aging, the wisdom of Jimmy Russell's famed "eight to ten years" sweet spot, and what a potential 17-year expression might hold. Whether you're a fan of massively aged, oak-forward bourbon or prefer your whiskey at its most expressive midpoint, the Calumet Farm lineup offers a rare chance to taste the same barrels across multiple years — and to draw your own conclusions about where Kentucky time hits its peak.

Full Transcript

Mike Hyatt Tasting Bourbon Small Batch Kentucky Calumet Farm Western Spirits Barton 1792 aged bourbon Kentucky straight bourbon 14 year bourbon 15 year bourbon 16 year bourbon bourbon tasting bourbon maturation Bowling Green Kentucky rye mash bill over-aged bourbon bourbon review barrel aging Sazerac horse country Kentucky small batch bourbon bourbon lineup bourbon podcast