Skip to content
Episode 375 December 13, 2023 · 50:27
375. Christmas Cocktail Edition

375. Christmas Cocktail Edition

Holiday cocktail showdown! Larceny, Jack Daniel's Single Barrel, Screwball, and Cedar Ridge barrel proof go head-to-head in four festive Christmas drinks.

The Bourbon Road Media Player

Reviews

Show Notes

Jim Shannon and co-host Brian Hyatt gather at Brian and Leslie Hyatt's festively decorated Louisville home for the First Annual Christmas Cocktail Edition of The Bourbon Road. With the fireplace roaring, the tree lit, and stockings hung, Jim, Brian, and guests Leslie Hyatt and Melody Shannon each craft a holiday-themed cocktail and share it with the group. The evening blends bourbon history, seasonal traditions, and spirited conversation about Christmas memories — all while working through four very different holiday drinks.

On the Tasting Mat:

  • Wuthering Sunrise (Cocktail featuring Larceny Bourbon, Founders All Day IPA, mango puree, agave nectar, lemon juice, and bitters): A visually striking tequila-sunrise-style cocktail built around Heaven Hill's wheated Larceny Bourbon and a hoppy IPA backbone. The mango puree — made fresh in a Vitamix from frozen mango — adds tropical sweetness, while the Founders All Day IPA brings an unexpected but harmonious depth. Agave nectar rounds out the sweetness and a dash of bitters adds complexity. Crafted by Melody Shannon. (00:03:50)
  • Charlie Brown's Peanuts Christmas Eggnog (Cocktail featuring Screwball Peanut Butter Whiskey, RumChata, and eggnog, with a peanut butter and graham cracker rim): A dessert-forward holiday sipper that layers creamy eggnog with the cinnamon-and-dairy richness of RumChata — a blend of Caribbean rum, Mexican spice, and Wisconsin dairy cream — and the nutty sweetness of Screwball peanut butter whiskey. The peanut butter and graham cracker rim elevates the presentation and adds a textural crunch to every sip. Crafted by Leslie Hyatt. (00:12:04)
  • Tennessee Christmas Mule (Cocktail featuring Jack Daniel's Single Barrel, Sprite Cranberry, and fresh lime): A clean, refreshing riff on the classic mule built on the elevated backbone of Jack Daniel's Single Barrel Tennessee Whiskey. The Sprite Cranberry provides a lightly tart, effervescent base, while a squeeze of fresh lime juice sharpens the finish. Simple in construction but bright and palate-cleansing in execution. Crafted by Brian Hyatt. (00:27:52)
  • Christmas Bourbon Buck (Cocktail featuring Cedar Ridge Full Proof Barrel Proof Bourbon at 116 proof, cranberry juice, lemon juice, muddled fresh cranberries, ginger beer, and simple syrup): Rooted in a 19th-century Kentucky tradition, the buck is the precursor to the modern mule. Cedar Ridge's barrel-proof bourbon at 116 proof provides a rich, full-bodied foundation that somehow drinks gentler than its proof suggests. Muddled fresh cranberries add a festive blush color and subtle fruity depth, while cranberry juice and lemon juice contribute brightness, and simple syrup balances the tartness. Crafted by Jim Shannon. (00:38:38)

The evening wraps with warm laughter, Christmas memories ranging from corncob pipe gifts and pocket knives to peanut butter-and-depends gag exchanges, and a round of voting on the night's standout cocktail. It's a celebration of the season, good company, and the creativity that bourbon and whiskey bring to the holiday table. Merry Christmas from the entire Bourbon Road family — and stay tuned for the upcoming blind bottle share episode to close out the year.

Full Transcript

Bourbon Road podcast Christmas cocktail Larceny bourbon Jack Daniel's Single Barrel Cedar Ridge barrel proof bourbon Screwball peanut butter whiskey RumChata Founders All Day IPA bourbon buck Kentucky mule holiday whiskey cocktail mango bourbon cocktail eggnog whiskey cranberry bourbon Jim Shannon Brian Hyatt Tennessee whiskey cocktail barrel proof bourbon corn whiskey history holiday bourbon drinks

The Conversation