Skip to content
Episode 375 December 13, 2023 · 50:27
375. Christmas Cocktail Edition

375. Christmas Cocktail Edition

Christmas cocktail showdown! Larceny, Screwball, Jack Daniel's Single Barrel & Cedar Ridge Barrel Proof go head-to-head in 4 original holiday drinks.

The Bourbon Road Media Player

Tasting Notes

Show Notes

Jim Shannon and co-host Brian Hyatt gather at Brian and Leslie Hyatt's home for The Bourbon Road's first annual Christmas Cocktail Edition. With the fireplace roaring, the tree lit, and the stockings hung, the crew — joined by Leslie Hyatt and Melody Shannon — settle in for a festive evening of four original holiday cocktails, swapping Christmas memories, family traditions, and a little friendly competition along the way.

On the Tasting Mat:

  • Wuthering Sunrise (cocktail featuring Larceny Bourbon): A creative holiday cocktail crafted by Melody Shannon built on 1.5 oz of Larceny Bourbon, mango purée, agave nectar, lemon juice, a dash of bitters, and Founders All Day IPA. The IPA lends an unmistakable craft-beer backbone while the mango — made from a homemade frozen purée — delivers a tropical brightness. The bitters add just enough complexity to tie it all together in a drink that drinks almost like a tropical whiskey sour with effervescence. (00:03:50)
  • Charlie Brown's Peanuts Christmas Eggnog (cocktail featuring Screwball Peanut Butter Whiskey & RumChata): Leslie Hyatt's showstopper of the evening, presented in a glass rimmed with creamy peanut butter and crushed graham crackers. The body of the drink combines Screwball peanut butter whiskey, RumChata — a blend of Caribbean rum, Mexican spice, and Wisconsin dairy cream — and classic store-bought eggnog. The result is a rich, dessert-like sipper that is warm with cinnamon and vanilla from the eggnog and deeply creamy from the RumChata. The peanut butter rim adds a nutty, textural contrast with every sip. (00:12:09)
  • Tennessee Christmas Mule (cocktail featuring Jack Daniel's Single Barrel): Brian Hyatt's riff on the classic mule keeps things elegantly simple: Jack Daniel's Single Barrel Tennessee Whiskey, half a fresh lime, and Sprite Cranberry soda. The result is tart, bright, and refreshing — the cranberry-laced Sprite providing a festive twist on traditional ginger beer while the lime juice cuts through and the high-proof single barrel adds a serious whiskey backbone beneath it all. (00:27:52)
  • Christmas Bourbon Buck (cocktail featuring Cedar Ridge Full Proof Bourbon): Jim Shannon's take on the historic Kentucky corn buck, updated for the holiday season. Built with 1.5 oz of Cedar Ridge Barrel Proof Bourbon at 116 proof, cranberry juice, fresh lemon juice, simple syrup, and muddled whole cranberries, this cocktail pours a striking blush-pink hue. The muddled cranberries add viscosity and a subtle fruity nuttiness rather than an overpowering tartness, while the barrel-proof bourbon brings depth and warmth without feeling hot. (00:37:02)

Christmas traditions, family memories, peanut butter and jelly cocktail pairings, and plenty of holiday cheer fill the spaces between pours. Cheers from the whole Bourbon Road family — Merry Christmas, Roadies, and we will see you down the Bourbon Road.

Full Transcript

Larceny bourbon Screwball whiskey RumChata Jack Daniel's Single Barrel Cedar Ridge bourbon barrel proof bourbon Christmas cocktails bourbon cocktails holiday whiskey drinks bourbon mule eggnog cocktail peanut butter whiskey Founders All Day IPA Tennessee whiskey Kentucky bourbon whiskey cocktail recipes holiday entertaining mango bourbon cocktail cranberry bourbon bourbon road podcast